Judge Acquits Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum Fraud Case

A Manhattan federal judge ruled that a trading strategy against crypto bots did not amount to criminal wire fraud.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Financial Crime

Judge Acquits Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum Fraud Case

Live Poll

Should exploiting other traders' bots on blockchains be prosecuted as fraud?

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted a motion for acquittal, ruling that prosecutors failed to show material misrepresentations by one of two brothers accused of a $25 million Ethereum exploit. The brothers used bait transactions to manipulate other traders' sandwich bots before intercepting their trades, and the transactions were not conducted on a regulated market.

Why it matters

The ruling addresses whether manipulating automated trading bots on a blockchain constitutes wire fraud under U.S. law. The outcome bears on how courts treat on-chain trading strategies that exploit maximal extractable value (MEV) bots.

The brothers were arrested in May 2024 and the court granted the acquittal on wire fraud charges in November 2026 after a November 2025 mistrial. Whether prosecutors will appeal the decision has not been reported.

The players

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke

Jessica Clarke is a federal judge serving in the Southern District of New York, which covers Manhattan.

The details

Prosecutors alleged that the brothers replaced the normal MEV transactions of other traders' bots with malicious ones to intercept their trades. The judge found the government did not prove the material misrepresentations needed for a wire fraud conviction.

Timeline

  1. April 2023: MEV bots lost over $25 million in seconds in the alleged exploit.

  2. May 2024: The brothers were arrested.

  3. November 2025: A mistrial was declared after the jury deadlocked.

  4. November 16, 2026: The judge granted the motion for acquittal.

Legal Context

The acquittal follows a November 2025 mistrial in the same case, when the jury deadlocked on the wire fraud charges. The ruling turns on whether on-chain manipulation of automated trading bots meets the material misrepresentation standard that federal wire fraud law requires.

The ruling clarifies that manipulating automated trading bots on a blockchain may not be prosecuted as wire fraud when no material misrepresentation is shown. Traders on decentralized networks face uncertainty about which on-chain strategies carry criminal exposure.

The takeaway

Automated trading on public blockchains is drawing closer legal scrutiny, and courts will need to define where aggressive strategy ends and fraud begins. Readers following crypto markets should watch for appellate action on this ruling.

Further reading

Explore more financial crime coverage to see how courts are handling cases involving digital assets.

Live Poll

Should exploiting other traders' bots on blockchains be prosecuted as fraud?