Natural Disaster Risk Pressures Home Values

A Cotality study finds rising catastrophe risks are making home insurance harder to obtain and weighing on property values.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Severe Weather

Natural Disaster Risk Pressures Home Values

Live Poll

Has your homeowners insurance become harder to get or renew in the past few years?

Cotality published a study reporting that rising natural catastrophe risks are making insurance harder to obtain and putting pressure on home values. Miami's home market flattened and Naples saw price growth fall 8.3% starting earlier in 2026.

Why it matters

Insurance nonrenewals tied to hurricane, wildfire and flood exposure can reduce the buyers a market can attract and pull on home values. Cotality says historical weather patterns are becoming less reliable predictors of future risk.

Cotality's report examines homes in the U.S. and Australia, with Lake County, California recording a 7.6% insurance nonrenewal rate in 2023. The analysis does not isolate how much of the observed price softening stems from insurance availability versus other market factors.

The players

Cotality

Cotality is a property data and analytics company whose research tracks how climate and catastrophe risk affect real estate values.

The details

Cotality's analysis uses historical weather patterns to assess properties exposed to hurricane winds, wildfire and inland flooding. Miami and Naples, Florida, along with Houston, Texas, are the top three U.S. cities with the most homes exposed to triple-threat natural perils over the next 30 years.

Timeline

  1. 2023: Dare County, North Carolina saw 13% of property insurance policies not renewed.

  2. 2022: Lismore, Mullumbimby and Ballina in Australia experienced flooding.

  3. April 2026: Allianz released a report on severe convective storm losses.

  4. 2026: California experienced negative home-price growth.

  5. 2040: Kiowa County, Oklahoma is projected to face $1.4 million in additional annual storm losses.

Seasonal Patterns

Cotality's Weather rewrites home value report argues that historical weather patterns are becoming less reliable predictors of future risk. Its findings on Miami, Naples and Houston suggest that the risk picture for coastal Florida and Texas is shifting faster than past averages would indicate.

Homeowners in high-exposure areas should check whether their insurer has signaled a nonrenewal, since Dare County and Lake County data show nonrenewals are already occurring. Buyers in exposed markets such as Miami, Naples and Houston may want to factor insurance availability into purchase decisions.

The takeaway

Insurance availability is becoming a key factor in home values, not just a line item on an annual bill. Buyers and owners in high-exposure regions should weigh coverage costs and nonrenewal risk alongside price when assessing a property.

Further reading

For more on how storms and floods are reshaping the market, see Severe Weather coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Claims Journal.

Live Poll

Has your homeowners insurance become harder to get or renew in the past few years?