Bully Ray Says Cody Rhodes Wears Thin on Fans
Bully Ray said on Busted Open Radio that fan support for Cody Rhodes is eroding night by night.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Wrestling

Former wrestler Bully Ray said WWE fans are growing indifferent to Cody Rhodes, whose reception has turned more mixed during his 2026 feud with Randy Orton. He made the comments on Busted Open Radio last week.
Why it matters
The remarks point to a shift in how Rhodes is received as a babyface, a question that bears on storyline direction and fan engagement for the company's top-tier talent. Bully Ray attributed the erosion to a specific moment in the Orton feud.
The assessment rests on a commentator's observations rather than measured audience data, with no crowd-reaction metrics or ratings cited. Whether the shift in Rhodes' reception extends beyond the Orton feud remains unclear.
The players
Bully Ray
Bully Ray is a former professional wrestler and commentator known for his work in WWE and other promotions, and he hosts Busted Open Radio.
Cody Rhodes
Cody Rhodes is a professional wrestler who has held major WWE championships and built his reputation as a leading babyface.
Randy Orton
Randy Orton is a veteran WWE wrestler and multi-time world champion whose feud with Rhodes drew the mixed reaction discussed.
The details
Bully Ray said Rhodes did not kick Randy Orton at the first opportunity, and that this moment began the erosion of his babyface support. He compared the reaction to the one John Cena received during his heyday, describing fans as increasingly indifferent to Rhodes.
Timeline
Towards the end of his time in AEW, many believed Rhodes had run his course as a babyface.
Throughout 2026, Rhodes received a more mixed reaction during his feud with Randy Orton.
Last week, Bully Ray made the erosion comments on Busted Open Radio.
Season Trajectory
Bully Ray's comparison places Cody Rhodes alongside John Cena's peak babyface run, a reference point that highlights how fan reaction can shift across a career. The claim suggests a turning point in Rhodes' standing that the broader WWE storyline will need to address.
Fans following Rhodes' storyline may watch how the crowd reaction develops in upcoming WWE shows. The comments give viewers a benchmark for judging whether the reaction changes.
The takeaway
Fan reaction to a wrestler can shift gradually across a feud, so tracking live crowd response offers a clearer view than any single moment. Readers can compare later shows against the reaction described here.
Further reading
For more on the wrestling storylines discussed, see the Wrestling section.






