Pettitte Enters Second-to-Last Year on Hall Ballot
Andy Pettitte, who received 27.9% of the vote in 2025, needs 75% for election and faces his final years on the BBWAA writers' ballot.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Baseball

Live Poll
Do you trust Hall of Fame voters to judge players fairly?
Andy Pettitte entered his second-to-last year on the Baseball Writers Association of America Hall of Fame ballot, with ballots sent to more than 400 BBWAA voting members. Pettitte received 27.9% of the vote in 2025, well short of the 75% required for election.
Why it matters
Candidates can remain on the writers' ballot for up to 10 years, so Pettitte's standing this year determines how much time remains for his case to gain support. The ballot includes 13 holdovers and 14 new candidates, shaping how voters weigh Pettitte against rivals.
Pettitte compiled a 256-153 record with a 3.85 ERA and 2,448 strikeouts over 18 seasons, while receiving 27.9% of the vote in 2025 against a 75% threshold. Whether his vote share will rise enough to reach election remains unresolved.
The players
Andy Pettitte
Andy Pettitte is a retired left-handed pitcher whose 18-season career includes multiple World Series titles with the New York Yankees.
Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA)
The Baseball Writers' Association of America is the professional body whose members vote annually on candidates for the National Baseball Hall of Fame.
The details
Ballots are sent to BBWAA members with 10 or more consecutive years of MLB coverage, and Pettitte appeared on 13.5% of ballots in 2024 before rising to 27.9% in 2025. Pettitte admitted taking human growth hormone in 2002 and 2004 while recovering from injuries, and he pitched for the Astros from 2004-06.
Timeline
2002 and 2004: Pettitte took human growth hormone while recovering from injuries.
2004-06: Pettitte pitched for the Astros.
2024: Pettitte received 13.5% of ballot votes.
2025: Pettitte received 27.9% of ballot votes.
Dec. 6: Results of the contemporary era ballot will be announced.
Season Trajectory
Pettitte's trajectory under the BBWAA's 75% threshold and 10-year ballot limit makes his path to Cooperstown dependent on sustained vote gains. Comparing his 27.9% share to Chase Utley's 59.1% shows how far the candidate pool remains from the election bar.
Pettitte needs to roughly triple his 2025 vote share to reach the 75% threshold, so his election hinges on significant shifts in voter sentiment over the next two years. Fans tracking Hall of Fame races can watch the Dec. 6 announcement for early signals on the broader ballot.
The takeaway
Hall of Fame candidacies often move slowly over multiple ballot cycles, so a candidate's trajectory matters as much as any single year's result. Pettitte's path depends on whether his vote share keeps climbing before his eligibility ends.
What happens next
The results of the contemporary era ballot will be announced Dec. 6, and elected candidates will be inducted into the Hall of Fame next July as part of the Class of 2027.
Further reading
Explore more Baseball coverage for context on Hall of Fame races and player careers.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Houston Chronicle.
Live Poll
Do you trust Hall of Fame voters to judge players fairly?






