Caleb Downs Recounts Cowboys' Pre-Colts Questions
The Cowboys safety revealed coaches asked him about facing his brother Josh Downs before their Week 9 game.
Updated on Nov. 15, 2026 in Football

Dallas Cowboys nickel back Caleb Downs said coaches questioned him about covering his brother, Indianapolis Colts receiver Josh Downs, ahead of their Week 9 matchup. The Cowboys won the game, and Caleb held Josh to zero catches on two targets when covering him.
Why it matters
The matchup pitted two brothers against each other in a regular-season game, drawing attention to how teams handle personal connections in game planning. The Colts later traded Josh Downs to the Kansas City Chiefs, changing his place in the league.
In Week 9, Josh Downs was held to zero catches on two targets when covered by his brother Caleb, who is about three and a half years older. Josh had been leading the Colts in receiving yards before the Colts traded him to the Chiefs.
The players
Caleb Downs
Caleb Downs is a Dallas Cowboys defensive back who played nickel in the Week 9 game against the Colts, where he covered his brother.
Josh Downs
Josh Downs is an Indianapolis Colts wide receiver who was traded to the Kansas City Chiefs and attended Caleb Downs' draft ceremony.
Dallas Cowboys
The Dallas Cowboys are a National Football League franchise based in Dallas, Texas, who won the Week 9 game against the Colts.
Indianapolis Colts
The Indianapolis Colts are a National Football League franchise based in Indianapolis, Indiana, who traded Josh Downs to the Chiefs.
Kansas City Chiefs
The Kansas City Chiefs are a National Football League franchise based in Kansas City, Missouri, who acquired Josh Downs in a trade.
The details
Caleb Downs played nickel defensive back and was matched against Josh Downs, a wide receiver, in the Cowboys' Week 9 win over the Colts. Caleb said Cowboys coaches emphasized Josh's motion and route timing while preparing the defense, and the brothers later discussed the matchup on their Downs 2 Business podcast.
Timeline
Week 9 of the 2026 NFL season: the Cowboys played the Colts, with Caleb covering Josh.
Days after the game: the brothers discussed the matchup on the Downs 2 Business podcast.
Before the trade: Josh Downs was leading the Colts in receiving yards.
2026 NFL regular season: the Cowboys and Chiefs do not face each other.
Season Trajectory
Brothers facing each other in the NFL, as with the Manning brothers in past seasons, is a rare occurrence that draws attention beyond a single game. The Cowboys' Week 9 win over the Colts is one result within a 2026 regular season in which the Cowboys and Chiefs do not meet.
The matchup affects fantasy managers tracking Josh Downs, whose production dropped after his trade to the Chiefs and who was held to zero catches on two targets in Week 9. Readers following the Cowboys' secondary can track how Caleb Downs performs in nickel coverage in the coming weeks.
The takeaway
The story shows how personal relationships can become a tactical factor in professional sports, as coaches weigh a player's connection to an opponent when assigning coverage. Fans and analysts can watch how such matchups play out when rosters change.
Further reading
For more on the teams involved, browse our Football coverage.










