DOJ Seeks Dismissal of Mar-a-Lago Records Suit

The Justice Department asked a federal judge in Maryland to dismiss a LegalEagle lawsuit seeking recovery of Mar-a-Lago records.

Updated on Nov. 14, 2026 in Law

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain stone government building facade with a limp flag, in deep red, cream, and charcoal.
The Justice Department asked a federal judge in Maryland to dismiss a LegalEagle lawsuit seeking recovery of Mar-a-Lago presidential records. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should the government be required to recover allegedly lost presidential records?

The Department of Justice has asked a federal judge in Maryland to dismiss a lawsuit brought by LegalEagle seeking recovery of records from Mar-a-Lago. U.S. District Judge Theodore Chuang has issued a preservation order in the case.

Why it matters

The motion argues that the Presidential Records Act imposes no duty on the government to seize presidential records and that the National Archives' referral decisions are committed to its sole and unreviewable discretion. The outcome could shape how FOIA litigants can pursue presidential records held outside federal custody.

The Justice Department's motion to dismiss was filed in federal court in Maryland, and the FOIA litigation has run nearly two years against the FBI for first-term records. The extraction does not report a ruling on the motion or a resolution of the preservation order.

The players

Department of Justice

The federal department responsible for enforcing federal law and representing the government in court, which filed the motion to dismiss.

National Archives

The federal agency charged with preserving and managing presidential and federal records, and the target of the FOIA lawsuits.

Donald Trump

The 47th President of the United States, whose Mar-a-Lago records are at the center of the litigation.

The details

The DOJ argues that plaintiffs concede the court may not compel the National Archives to refer an alleged loss of presidential records, and that the litigation would incentivize FOIA litigants to sue before agencies can satisfy requests. The plaintiff raised concerns about an April 1 Office of Legal Counsel opinion that gave the president authority to ignore the Presidential Records Act, and Judge Chuang allowed alternative service of a subpoena on the president.

Timeline

  1. February 2025: Trump posted that the FBI had returned the Mar-a-Lago materials to Florida.

  2. April 1, 2025: A DOJ Office of Legal Counsel opinion addressing the Presidential Records Act was issued.

  3. 2022: The FBI searched Mar-a-Lago for classified documents.

Legal Context

The dispute centers on the Presidential Records Act, and the government's position that the statute imposes no duty to seize presidential records tests how far that law reaches. The case is one of several FOIA suits brought against the National Archives over presidential records.

The ruling on the motion to dismiss will determine whether FOIA requesters can pursue presidential records through court. Readers following government transparency should watch how the court treats the Presidential Records Act and the preservation order.

The takeaway

The case may determine whether the Presidential Records Act can be enforced through FOIA litigation against the National Archives. Its resolution will show how much authority agencies retain over decisions to refer alleged record losses.

Further reading

For related coverage, see Law in the politics section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Law & Crime.

Live Poll

Should the government be required to recover allegedly lost presidential records?