Newton Defends Steve Smith Sr. After SportsCenter Jab

Cam Newton came to Steve Smith Sr.'s defense after SportsCenter hosts joked that Smith's Hall of Fame career never reached the playoffs often.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Football

Newton Defends Steve Smith Sr. After SportsCenter Jab

SportsCenter hosts Gary Striewski and Randy Scott joked that one can be a Hall of Fame player and never make the playoffs, a remark aimed at Steve Smith Sr. Smith later appeared as a guest on the show and responded on air, and Cam Newton defended him on the 4th&1 podcast.

Why it matters

The exchange highlights how sports broadcasters and former players debate the legacy of veterans whose individual achievements were not matched by team success. It also shows how social media interaction between athletes and media personalities can spill into televised commentary.

Smith finished with 1,031 catches for 14,731 yards and five Pro Bowl selections across 16 NFL seasons. He reached the playoffs in only five of those seasons, missing the postseason in 11.

The players

Steve Smith Sr.

A former NFL wide receiver who spent most of his 16-season career with the Carolina Panthers and was a five-time Pro Bowl selection.

Cam Newton

A former NFL quarterback and 2015 NFL MVP who played most of his career with the Carolina Panthers and later became a media analyst.

SportsCenter

ESPN's flagship sports news program, long one of the most widely watched sports highlight and commentary shows in the United States.

The details

Scott said on SportsCenter that one can be a Hall of Fame player and never make the playoffs, and Striewski denied having said those words. Smith followed both hosts on social media before appearing on the show, where the banter continued. Newton, who described the 2011 Panthers as a 'locker room of losers' in February 2025, later defended Smith on the 4th&1 podcast.

Timeline

  1. February 2025: Newton describes the 2011 Panthers as a 'locker room of losers.'

  2. 2016: Smith finishes his NFL career with 1,031 catches and 14,731 yards.

  3. November 13, 2026: Newton defends Smith on the 4th&1 podcast following the SportsCenter exchange.

Season Trajectory

The discussion echoes long-running debates over whether individual honors like Pro Bowl selections and receiving titles should outweigh a receiver's playoff record. Smith's case, with five playoff trips across 16 seasons, is frequently cited in that context.

The exchange is a reminder that fantasy and fan debates about veteran receivers often turn on playoff records as much as raw stats. Readers weighing a player's legacy can compare his counting numbers with his postseason history.

The takeaway

A player's career can be judged by individual milestones or team results, and the two often tell different stories. Weighing both gives a fuller picture of a veteran's legacy.

Further reading

For more NFL coverage tied to debates like this, explore the Football section.