Utility Return Cuts Could Trim Bills Modestly

A Concentric Energy Advisors report examines how lowering allowed utility profits would affect residential electric bills.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Utilities

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a single steel transmission pylon with taut copper cables against a navy and cream field, evoking the electricity infrastructure behind utility profit debates.
Concentric Energy Advisors found cutting utilities' allowed profit rates could trim residential electric bills modestly, while raising borrowing costs for grid upgrades. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Concentric Energy Advisors published a report estimating that cutting utilities' allowed return on equity would lower typical residential bills, studying 13 electric utilities in the PJM region. Lawmakers in New York and Pennsylvania have separately proposed tying utility profit rates to Treasury yields.

Why it matters

Affordability is a significant concern for ratepayers, but the report suggests reducing utility returns would provide limited short-term relief. Higher borrowing costs could offset some savings and make it harder for utilities to fund grid improvements.

Profit from utility shareholders makes up about 5% of a normal electric bill, so allowed-return cuts affect only a small share of total charges. The modeled savings depend on borrowing costs staying flat, a condition the report does not guarantee.

The players

Concentric Energy Advisors

Concentric Energy Advisors is a consulting firm that provides economic and financial analysis to energy companies, utilities and regulators.

Arizona Public Service

Arizona Public Service is the largest electric utility in Arizona, serving a major share of the state's residential and business customers.

The details

Return on equity is the profit rate regulators allow utilities to earn on investor money. Pennsylvania's House Bill 2224 and New York's Senate Bill 10424 would set standard returns at the 10-year Treasury rate plus two percentage points and would let utilities use competitive bidding to set different profit rates for investors.

Timeline

  1. 2020: A proposed formula would have set allowed returns below 3%.

  2. 2021: Arizona regulators cut Arizona Public Service's allowed return from 10% to 8.7%.

  3. August 2021 to November 2022: Concentric's borrowing costs rose 1.14 points above benchmark.

  4. June: Pennsylvania's House passed its bill unanimously.

  5. Last week: Concentric published its report.

Market Landscape

Pennsylvania and New York's proposals would tie utility profit rates to the 10-year Treasury rate plus two percentage points, a formula that echoes the 2020 proposal that would have set allowed returns below 3%. Arizona's 2021 cut of Arizona Public Service's allowed return from 10% to 8.7% offers a recent regulatory precedent for lowering utility profit rates.

For a typical household, a one-point cut in allowed utility returns would reduce a residential bill by about 0.7%, which could mean roughly $1 on a $150 monthly bill. Higher borrowing costs could offset that savings, so ratepayers may see little net change.

The takeaway

Cutting allowed utility returns can trim bills, but the savings depend on borrowing costs, which can rise in response. Ratepayers should watch whether proposed state formulas account for financing costs that affect long-term grid investment.

Further reading

For broader context on how electricity pricing and regulation work, explore more Utilities coverage.