Utility Chairs Criticize DOE Plant Retirement Orders

Iowa and South Dakota commission chairs say federal delays to fossil-fired plant retirements are hurting grid planning and raising customer bills.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Utilities

Isometric editorial illustration in oxblood, teal, mustard and cream showing lattice transmission towers and a squat plant with cooling towers across a flat plain.
Iowa and South Dakota utility commission chairs criticized federal Department of Energy orders delaying fossil-fired plant retirements, saying they hinder grid planning and raise customer bills. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Have your electricity bills gone up over the past year?

At a recent MISO meeting, the chairs of the Iowa and South Dakota utility commissions criticized Department of Energy orders that delay the retirement of fossil-fired power plants. The chairs said the orders have hindered grid planning and driven up customer bills.

Why it matters

The orders affect how regional grid operators plan for reliability and how much ratepayers pay for electricity across the country. Data from MISO indicates the orders are not necessary to maintain reliability, adding to the debate over federal intervention in power generation.

MISO data shows the DOE delay orders are not necessary to maintain grid reliability, though the source does not quantify the resulting cost increases to customers. The size of the bill impact and the number of affected plants remain unspecified.

The players

Department of Energy

The federal agency that issues emergency orders delaying the retirement of fossil-fired power plants.

Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO)

The regional grid operator serving parts of the central United States, which hosted the meeting where the criticism was voiced.

The details

The DOE issues orders delaying fossil-fired plant retirements across the country. Commission chairs Sarah Martz of Iowa and counterparts in South Dakota voiced the criticism at a MISO meeting, with Martz describing the orders as adding chaos and uncertainty.

Timeline

  1. September: A federal appeals court overturned an emergency coal plant order in Michigan.

  2. Last month: A US House bill was introduced that would ban the DOE tactic altogether.

  3. Recently: Commission chairs criticized the DOE orders at a MISO meeting.

Market Landscape

The DOE's use of emergency orders to keep fossil-fired plants running has become a recurring point of conflict, as shown by the September appeals court reversal of a Michigan coal plant order. The dispute now spans state regulators, regional grid operators and Congress, which is weighing a bill to ban the practice.

If the DOE orders keep older plants open, the costs of running them can flow through to customer bills, according to the commission chairs. A proposed House bill would ban the tactic entirely, which could affect future electricity rates.

The takeaway

Federal decisions about when power plants can close are increasingly shaping regional grid planning and household electricity costs. Watching how Congress and the courts respond will indicate whether emergency retirement delays remain a standard federal tool.

Further reading

Explore more on utilities coverage shaping power prices and grid reliability across the United States.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Energy Central.

Live Poll

Have your electricity bills gone up over the past year?