USPTO Returns Merits Reviews of Patent Challenges to PTAB
Starting November 16, 2026, merits-based institution decisions for IPR and PGR proceedings move from the Director to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board.
Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Remote Work

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office issued a memorandum from Director John A. Squires and General Counsel John F. Duffy returning merits-based institution decisions for inter partes review and post-grant review to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. The change applies to any IPR or PGR that does not yet have a notice referring the case for merits consideration.
Why it matters
The shift reflects PTAB judges' assistance on more than 325 merits-based decisions and related training programs over the past year. Director Squires will continue to review discretionary, non-merits considerations in institution policy.
The PTAB has assisted in over 325 merits-based decisions, and the new institution process takes effect November 16, 2026. The source does not report how many pending IPR or PGR petitions will be affected by the transition.
The players
John A. Squires
John A. Squires is the Director of the United States Patent and Trademark Office, who co-signed the memorandum and will continue reviewing discretionary institution considerations.
John F. Duffy
John F. Duffy is the General Counsel of the United States Patent and Trademark Office, who co-signed the memorandum returning institution decisions to the PTAB.
United States Patent and Trademark Office
The United States Patent and Trademark Office is the federal agency responsible for granting patents and registering trademarks in the United States.
The details
Under the memorandum, the PTAB will determine on the Director's behalf whether to institute IPR and PGR trials based on merits. The Director will keep reviewing non-merits, discretionary considerations, which the USPTO says lets it apply those factors consistently while drawing on judges' technical expertise.
Timeline
Last year: developments prompted the return of merits considerations to the PTAB.
November 11, 2026: USPTO memorandum announcing the change was published.
November 16, 2026: Merits-based institution decisions move to the PTAB.
Market Landscape
The change builds on the post-America Invents Act framework that created IPR and PGR as PTAB proceedings, shaping how challenges to issued patents are filed and decided. It moves institution authority between the Director and the PTAB, a reallocation that affects how patent challengers and patent holders approach these proceedings.
Patent holders and companies facing IPR or PGR challenges will see institution decisions handled by PTAB judges starting November 16, 2026. Parties with pending petitions should track whether their case has a notice referring it for merits consideration.
The takeaway
Patent challengers and patent holders should review how the November 16, 2026 change affects any IPR or PGR they are pursuing or defending. Consulting current USPTO guidance on pending petitions can clarify which institution rules apply to a given case.
Further reading
For broader context on how workplace and professional structures are changing, see Remote Work coverage.






