Researchers Argue Dire Wolf Project Isn't De-Extinction

Two Wheaton College scientists say Colossal Biosciences' gene-edited wolves do not restore a lost evolutionary lineage.

Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Life Sciences

Researchers Argue Dire Wolf Project Isn't De-Extinction

Marine biologist Andrew Davinack and biochemist Charlotte Daniels, both of Wheaton College in Massachusetts, argue that Colossal Biosciences did not achieve de-extinction when it announced dire wolves in 2025. Their argument, published in Biology Letters, introduces the term lineage-genome conflation to describe the mischaracterization.

Why it matters

The researchers contend that extinction ends an evolutionary lineage, so editing a related species' genome cannot recover it. Their critique bears on how the public and scientists interpret claims about bringing extinct animals back.

The argument is a peer-reviewed commentary in Biology Letters, not a new experiment, and it contrasts the dire wolf's more than 10,000-year-old environment with grey wolf cells edited for larger bodies, bigger teeth, and paler coats. The authors do not say whether they consider any future de-extinction effort possible.

The players

Colossal Biosciences

Colossal Biosciences is a biotechnology company that announced its dire wolf de-extinction project in 2025.

Andrew Davinack

Andrew Davinack is a marine biologist at Wheaton College in Massachusetts and a co-author of the critique.

Charlotte Daniels

Charlotte Daniels is a biochemist at Wheaton College in Massachusetts and a co-author who coined the term lineage-genome conflation.

The details

Colossal Biosciences made genetic edits to grey wolf cells to produce animals with dire wolf-like characteristics. Davinack and Daniels propose that preserved cells or preserved embryos offer a more promising route for de-extinction, citing a 2003 attempt with the Pyrenean ibex, which did not survive.

Timeline

  1. 2003: Scientists used cell preservation with the Pyrenean ibex; the animal did not survive.

  2. 2025: Colossal Biosciences announced the de-extinction of the dire wolf.

  3. November 11, 2026: The researchers' argument was published in Biology Letters.

The Big Picture

The critique revisits the 2003 Pyrenean ibex cell-preservation attempt, in which the revived animal did not survive, to argue that preserved cells and embryos are a stronger route than genome editing. It challenges the idea that a related species' edited genome can stand in for a lost evolutionary lineage.

The critique matters to readers who follow headlines about revived species, because it separates recovering genetic traits from restoring an extinct lineage. Readers evaluating such claims can ask whether an announced animal is a related species with edited genes or a true continuation of the original line.

The takeaway

Claims of de-extinction depend on what counts as the same species, and the critique offers a precise term, lineage-genome conflation, for spotting when edited animals are being presented as revived ones. Keeping that distinction in mind helps readers weigh future announcements.

Further reading

Explore more in Life Sciences for context on how researchers evaluate efforts to revive extinct species.