Supreme Court Declines Rieth-Riley Union Withdrawal Case
The justices turned away an employer's petition over an NLRB bargaining order enforced by the Sixth Circuit.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Unions

The Supreme Court denied certiorari in Rieth-Riley Construction Co. v. NLRB, docket No. 26-306, leaving in place a Sixth Circuit decision enforcing an NLRB bargaining order against the company. The employer had argued the Board rewrote its 1958 Retail Associates precedent on multiemployer bargaining withdrawal.
Why it matters
The ruling leaves intact the Sixth Circuit's conclusion that the union timely withdrew from a multiemployer bargaining unit. The case shows how the NLRB's interpretation of withdrawal timing can determine whether employers must bargain with unions.
The Supreme Court's denial of review leaves the Sixth Circuit's enforcement of the NLRB bargaining order in place against Rieth-Riley Construction Co. The NLRB's findings included numerous unfair labor practices and a weeks-long lockout, while the employer contends the Board departed from the 1958 Retail Associates rule. The stub does not disclose the justices' reasoning for declining review.
The players
National Labor Relations Board
The federal agency that enforces U.S. labor law and issued the bargaining order against Rieth-Riley Construction Co. after finding numerous unfair labor practices.
Rieth-Riley Construction Co.
A Michigan-based construction company whose challenge to an NLRB bargaining order was turned away by the Supreme Court.
Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals
The federal appeals court whose panel held the NLRB was entitled to enforce the bargaining order against the company.
The details
The employer petitioned the Supreme Court, arguing the NLRB rewrote its 1958 Retail Associates precedent and that the Board's reading of the phrase 'the agreed-upon date' effectively nullifies part of that rule. The Sixth Circuit held the Board was entitled to enforce a bargaining order, concluding the union timely withdrew from a multiemployer bargaining arrangement after the contract modification deadline had passed without an agreed bargaining date.
Timeline
1958: The NLRB issued the Retail Associates decision governing multiemployer withdrawal.
2019: The Supreme Court decided Kisor v. Wilkie.
November 10, 2026: The Supreme Court denied certiorari in Rieth-Riley Construction Co. v. NLRB.
Legal Context
The dispute turns on the NLRB's 1958 Retail Associates decision, which governs when a union may withdraw from a multiemployer bargaining unit. The employer argues the Board's current reading effectively rewrites that precedent, a question the Supreme Court declined to take up.
The ruling leaves the NLRB's bargaining order in force, meaning Rieth-Riley Construction Co. must continue dealing with the union under the Board's decision. Employers in multiemployer bargaining arrangements should note how the Board currently reads withdrawal timing.
The takeaway
Employers and unions in multiemployer bargaining should track how the NLRB applies its withdrawal timing rules, since missed contract deadlines can shape whether bargaining obligations continue. The unresolved constitutional and assignment questions raised by the employer remain open.
Further reading
For related coverage, see more Unions reporting.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Vitallaw.










