Judge Keeps Sane Eligible for St. John's

A temporary restraining order lets St. John's forward Babacar Sane play while his lawsuit against the NCAA proceeds.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Basketball

Expressive editorial sports illustration of a gestural basketball player in red and white driving toward the hoop beside a mid-air ball, against deep navy.
St. John's forward Babacar Sane remains eligible this season after Judge Karina Alomar kept a temporary restraining order in place against the NCAA. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should college athletes who signed NBA contracts be allowed to play in college?

Judge Karina Alomar kept a temporary restraining order in place that allows St. John's forward Babacar Sane to remain eligible this season. Both parties were ordered to file memos of law by November 30, with a final submission deadline of December 3.

Why it matters

The NCAA deemed Sane ineligible over a signed Exhibit 10 contract with the NBA's Utah Jazz, and the case turns on whether that contract disqualifies him from college play. The ruling affects how the NCAA treats players who sign with professional teams in leagues with guaranteed minimum salaries.

Sane, a 23-year-old, is set to earn $1 million at St. John's this season under the temporary restraining order. The NCAA granted two years of reinstatement eligibility, and the judge has not announced when she will rule.

The players

Babacar Sane

A 23-year-old Senegalese forward for St. John's who played professionally in Germany last season before enrolling at the school.

Karina Alomar

The federal judge presiding over Sane's lawsuit against the NCAA, who kept the temporary restraining order in place.

NCAA

The National Collegiate Athletic Association, which ruled Sane ineligible over his professional contract and argues that players who sign with pro teams in leagues with guaranteed minimum salaries lose eligibility.

The details

Sane went undrafted in the 2024 NBA Draft and signed an Exhibit 10 contract with the Utah Jazz, who later waived him before training camp and offered a small bonus to play in the G League. He committed to St. John's after a season in Germany, and the NCAA called no witnesses in the hearing. Both sides stipulated that the signed Exhibit 10 contract is the sole issue in the case.

Timeline

  1. 2024 NBA Draft: Sane went undrafted and signed an Exhibit 10 contract with the Utah Jazz.

  2. November 30: Deadline for both parties to file memos of law.

  3. December 3: Final deadline for all submissions in the case.

Season Trajectory

The NCAA's rule on professional contracts is being tested as players increasingly sign Exhibit 10 deals before college. The temporary restraining order keeps Sane in the lineup while the eligibility question is decided, which could shape roster planning for St. John's.

Sane remains eligible for a minimum of seven more games, so St. John's rotation is set for now. If the NCAA prevails on appeal, the team could lose its forward mid-season.

The takeaway

Eligibility rules around pro contracts remain unsettled, so players weighing a G League or Exhibit 10 deal should understand how the NCAA may treat them. Watch the December 3 filings for the next signal on how this case may be decided.

What happens next

Both parties must file memos of law by November 30, with all submissions due December 3, and the judge has not announced a ruling date.

Further reading

For more on college hoops eligibility fights, see our Basketball coverage.

Live Poll

Should college athletes who signed NBA contracts be allowed to play in college?