Judge Lets Video Privacy Claim Against BBC Proceed
A federal judge in New York kept one privacy claim alive while dismissing other claims in a proposed class action against BBC Global News US LLC.
Updated on Nov. 6, 2026 in Media
Live Poll
Do you trust websites to keep your viewing habits private from third parties?
Judge J. Paul Oetken of the Southern District of New York allowed one Video Privacy Protection Act claim to proceed against BBC Global News US LLC. The judge dismissed the plaintiffs' common law and California and New York statutory claims.
Why it matters
The ruling lets a proposed class action over alleged sharing of viewers' video-viewing information move forward under federal privacy law. The dismissal of the state and common law claims narrows the case to the federal statute.
One of the plaintiffs' claims survived a motion to dismiss, while the remaining common law and state statutory claims were dismissed. Five consumers brought the suit against BBC Global News US LLC.
The players
J. Paul Oetken
J. Paul Oetken is a federal district judge of the Southern District of New York who issued the ruling on the motion to dismiss.
BBC Global News US LLC
BBC Global News US LLC is the U.S. entity of the British Broadcasting Corporation's news operation and the defendant in the proposed class action.
The details
The suit alleges the BBC website used tracking tools from Google LLC, Piano Analytics, and comScore Inc. to collect browsing data and email information, and that this information was shared with third parties. The judge found the plaintiffs adequately pleaded a Video Privacy Protection Act claim.
Timeline
November 5, 2026: Judge Oetken ruled on the motion to dismiss.
Industry Dynamics
The ruling applies the Video Privacy Protection Act of 1988, a federal statute that restricts disclosure of consumers' video rental and viewing records, to an online news website's use of third-party tracking tools. The surviving claim signals that federal video privacy law may reach digital media companies' web analytics practices.
Viewers of online video content may have their browsing and viewing information shared with third-party analytics providers. The surviving claim could affect how news sites that stream video handle data collection from U.S. audiences.
The takeaway
Readers who watch video on news websites may wish to review cookie and privacy settings, since tracking tools can collect viewing and browsing data. The ruling is an early stage decision and does not resolve the underlying claims.
Further reading
Explore more Media coverage to see how digital publishers handle audience data.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.
Live Poll
Do you trust websites to keep your viewing habits private from third parties?
