Defense Expert Blamed Gaudreau Brothers in Fatal Crash

A new defense report alleges the cyclists caused the fatal collision by riding while intoxicated without lights.

Updated on Oct. 8, 2026 in Accidents

Defense Expert Blamed Gaudreau Brothers in Fatal Crash

A defense expert has filed a report claiming that Johnny and Matthew Gaudreau created the hazard that led to their deaths in a 2024 collision. The report asserts that the brothers were riding bicycles without lights while intoxicated when they were struck by Sean M. Higgins.

Why it matters

The defense filing challenges the state police reconstruction of the accident, which aims to support the charges against Higgins. The defense is seeking additional electronic source data as they prepare for the upcoming trial.

Sean M. Higgins has been charged with aggravated manslaughter and reckless vehicular homicide, following his rejection of a 35-year prison plea offer. He currently faces a maximum potential sentence of 70 years.

The players

Sean M. Higgins

He is the 45-year-old defendant charged with aggravated manslaughter and reckless vehicular homicide.

Justin P. Schorr

He is a defense expert who authored a report analyzing the circumstances of the fatal collision.

Johnny Gaudreau

He was one of the two brothers killed in the accident on Route 551.

Matthew Gaudreau

He was the brother of Johnny Gaudreau and the second victim of the fatal collision.

The details

Defense expert Justin P. Schorr alleges that the collision occurred as Higgins was merging back into the northbound lane, rather than while passing on the right as prosecutors suggest. The report argues the cyclists were in the travel lane and lacked legally required lighting.

Aug. 29, 2024: Sean M. Higgins struck and killed the Gaudreau brothers.
Oct. 19, 2026: Next court hearing in the case.
Dec. 1, 2026: Scheduled start of jury selection.
Jan. 5, 2027: Scheduled start of the trial.

Legal Context

This case follows established legal patterns in the prosecution of vehicular homicide cases involving intoxicated drivers in New Jersey. The defense's focus on victim behavior marks a significant point of contention in the prosecution of vehicular homicide cases involving intoxicated drivers in New Jersey.

The ongoing legal proceedings serve as a reminder of the strict state safety laws regarding bicycle lighting and roadway conduct. Residents and cyclists should remain aware of local regulations concerning visibility equipment required for night riding.

The takeaway

The defense's report highlights the complexities involved in assigning liability during multi-factor fatal accidents. Both parties are preparing for a high-stakes trial that will determine the final legal outcome for the defendant.