All's Fair Will Return for Second Season in 2026

Disney Plus has officially renewed the series for a second season following its record-breaking debut.

Updated on Oct. 6, 2026 in Celebrities

Graphic editorial illustration of two theatrical masks, one comedy and one tragedy, in deep purple and gold. — Disney Plus has renewed its original series All's Fair for a second season, set to debut in November 2026. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you prefer your own opinion over critical reviews when deciding which shows to watch?

Disney Plus will release the second season of All's Fair in November 2026. The series stars Kim Kardashian, Sarah Paulson, Naomi Watts, Teyana Taylor, and Glenn Close.

Why it matters

Executives approved the renewal despite negative critical reception, citing the series' strong commercial performance during its premiere. The production team plans to shift the show's tone from drama to comedy to better align with audience perception.

The show secured the title of the biggest Hulu Original scripted series premiere in three years based on streaming data from its first three days. It holds a 3% rating on the Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer.

The players

Kim Kardashian

She is a prominent media personality, entrepreneur, and star of the series All's Fair.

Sarah Paulson

She is a critically acclaimed actress known for her extensive television and film work.

Naomi Watts

She is an Academy Award-nominated actress who serves as one of the leads in this Disney Plus series.

Teyana Taylor

She is a multi-talented artist, performer, and actress featured in the main cast of the show.

Glenn Close

She is an iconic award-winning actress who appears as a central figure in the series.

The details

The production team is shifting the series' creative focus toward comedy for the second season. This decision follows feedback from viewers who found the first season, which debuted in late 2025, to be comical.

The series initially debuted on Disney Plus in late 2025.
The second season is scheduled for release in November 2026.

Industry Dynamics

This renewal follows the historical trend of streaming platforms prioritizing high viewer engagement metrics over critical acclaim. It highlights how platforms leverage massive premiere audiences to justify continuing projects despite poor professional reviews.

Fans can expect the new season to arrive on Disney Plus in November 2026. The shift in tone suggests that viewers who engage with the series should prepare for a more overtly comedic experience compared to the first season.

The takeaway

Commercial success frequently dictates the longevity of streaming series even when critical reception is low. Audiences should note that producers often pivot creative strategies based on how viewers describe the content rather than what critics write.