Burchett Will Challenge Chevalier Seating in January 2027
Representative Tim Burchett plans a parliamentary motion to block New York nominee Darializa Avila Chevalier.
Updated on Oct. 3, 2026 in Legislative Policy
Live Poll
Should Congress block duly elected members from serving based on their past personal comments?
Representative Tim Burchett intends to challenge the seating of Democratic congressional nominee Darializa Avila Chevalier when Congress convenes in January 2027. The move aims to utilize a majority vote to prevent the candidate from taking office.
Why it matters
The challenge is rooted in Burchett's opposition to Chevalier based on her 2019 social media comments regarding the American flag and her involvement in a 2024 campus protest. This proposed action highlights the tension surrounding the constitutional authority of the House to judge member qualifications.
Burchett intends to leverage a simple majority vote to block the seating of the 13th Congressional District nominee before the oath of office. This action follows Chevalier's primary election victory and precedes the general election scheduled for November 3, 2026.
The players
Tim Burchett
He is a U.S. Representative from Tennessee who has expressed his intention to block a congressional nominee from being seated.
Darializa Avila Chevalier
She is the Democratic nominee for New York's 13th Congressional District and a participant in the 2024 Columbia University protests.
Jomo M. Williams
He is the candidate scheduled to face Chevalier in the 2026 general election for the 13th Congressional District of New York.
The details
Representative Burchett plans to cite Chevalier's past actions, including a 2019 post about using an American flag as a napkin and her 2024 participation in a Columbia University campus takeover, as the basis for his challenge. The effort faces significant legal hurdles given the 1969 Supreme Court ruling which limited the House's power to exclude members who meet established constitutional qualifications.
Timeline
2019: Chevalier commented on social media about using a flag as a napkin.
2024: Chevalier took part in the Columbia University campus takeover.
November 3, 2026: General election for New York's 13th Congressional District.
January 2027: The new Congress is scheduled to convene.
Political Context
The proposed challenge conflicts with the legal precedent established by the 1969 Supreme Court ruling in Powell v. McCormack. Opposition figures and constitutional scholars may argue that excluding a member who meets age, residency, and citizenship requirements exceeds the chamber's authority.
The challenge could delay the seating of a representative or force a lengthy constitutional debate within the House. Voters in the 13th Congressional District may see their representation tied up in internal legislative proceedings depending on the outcome of the challenge.
The takeaway
The effort to block a member-elect highlights the ongoing friction between political party goals and constitutional eligibility standards. Voters should note that the House's ability to police its own members remains a subject of intense legal and procedural scrutiny.
Further reading
Find more information on congressional rules and procedural standards in our Legislative Policy section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by New York Post.
Live Poll
Should Congress block duly elected members from serving based on their past personal comments?
