Appellate Court Heard SiriusXM Royalty Lawsuit Arguments

A federal panel weighed whether SoundExchange has legal standing to pursue $150 million in allegedly missing royalty payments.

Updated on Sept. 25, 2026 in Music — General

Isometric editorial illustration showing a pair of brass balance weights on a wooden plinth, symbolizing legal oversight in a payment dispute.
A Second Circuit appellate panel heard arguments Friday regarding a 150 million dollar royalty payment dispute between SiriusXM and SoundExchange. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should nonprofit groups be allowed to sue corporations on behalf of individuals they represent?

A Second Circuit appellate panel heard oral arguments on Friday regarding a legal battle between SoundExchange and SiriusXM. The nonprofit organization is seeking $150 million in unpaid royalties, a case that was previously dismissed by a lower court in 2025.

Why it matters

The outcome of this appeal will determine whether SoundExchange possesses the legal standing to enforce federal payment rights on behalf of artists. This case centers on the interpretation of the enforcement role authorized for the organization by Congress in 2002.

SoundExchange claims it is owed $150 million in royalties due to accounting practices that allegedly shifted traffic between platforms. The organization has a historical track record of distributing over $5 billion in royalties to artists through 2018.

The players

SoundExchange

This is an independent nonprofit organization that serves as a central entity for the collection and distribution of digital performance royalties.

SiriusXM

This is a major American audio entertainment company that provides satellite radio and streaming services to millions of subscribers.

The details

SoundExchange alleges that SiriusXM diverted satellite traffic to streaming services to avoid payment obligations. A district court previously ruled that SoundExchange lacked the legal standing to pursue this enforcement action.

Timeline

  1. SoundExchange launched as an RIAA division in 2000.

  2. Congress authorized royalty collection entities in 2002.

  3. SoundExchange became an independent nonprofit in 2003.

  4. SoundExchange filed the lawsuit against SiriusXM in 2023.

  5. The appellate panel heard oral arguments on September 25, 2026.

Industry Dynamics

The appellate review marks a critical test of the 2002 congressional authorization for royalty collection entities, as the court determines if the law grants SoundExchange the power to litigate on behalf of performers. This dispute reflects broader tensions in the music industry regarding the evolving definitions of streaming platforms versus traditional satellite radio broadcast rights.

The resolution of this case could influence how streaming services and satellite radio providers structure their licensing agreements with rights holders. Listeners may see changes in the availability of specific content if royalty payment disputes alter the commercial relationship between major platforms.

The takeaway

This litigation highlights the complex legal mechanisms used to ensure creators are compensated for their work in the digital age. Artists and industry observers should monitor the court's decision as it could redefine the enforcement capabilities of royalty collection agencies.

Further reading

For more on how royalty structures impact the industry, visit the Music — General section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Court House News Service.

Live Poll

Should nonprofit groups be allowed to sue corporations on behalf of individuals they represent?