Pastor Questioned Historical Existence of Jesus

Rev. Babs Miller suggested that the virgin birth of Jesus mirrors ancient pagan beliefs.

Updated on Sept. 25, 2026 in Christianity

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a solitary stone church arch silhouette, evoking the solemnity of theological questioning.
Rev. Babs Miller of St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church sparked debate after questioning the historical existence of Jesus and traditional virgin birth narratives. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust religious leaders who publicly question foundational tenets of their own faith?

Rev. Babs Miller, the pastor of St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church, has questioned the historical existence of Jesus. In a recorded video, she also denied the virgin birth of Jesus, comparing the narrative to pagan beliefs.

Why it matters

The remarks have prompted a conversation regarding the role of traditional dogma within modern religious practice. Miller's call for a selective approach to faith challenges established theological frameworks held by many believers.

Rev. Babs Miller suggested a pick-and-choose approach to Christian faith for her followers. Her statements were made during a recorded video session at St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church.

The players

Rev. Babs Miller

Rev. Babs Miller serves as the pastor of St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church and recently articulated views challenging traditional Christian doctrines.

The details

During a recorded video session, Rev. Babs Miller encouraged viewers to adopt a selective approach to religious belief, suggesting they take what makes sense and leave the rest. She specifically expressed skepticism regarding the virgin birth, labeling it similar to pagan traditions.

Timeline

  1. The statements by the pastor were reported in September 2026.

Culture Shift

The questioning of core theological tenets follows a pattern established by the 1990s Jesus Seminar findings. Miller's remarks represent a departure from traditional adherence to established church dogma in favor of personal spiritual interpretation.

The statements may influence how congregants interpret biblical teachings during their own daily religious practices. Readers must decide whether this selective approach aligns with their personal commitment to traditional faith structures.

The takeaway

These remarks highlight the growing tension between institutional tradition and individualistic approaches to modern spirituality. Believers are often tasked with reconciling historical scholarship with long-standing religious narratives in their personal lives.

Further reading

For more information on current theological debates, visit the Christianity section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by CBN.com - The Christian Broadcasting Network.

Live Poll

Do you trust religious leaders who publicly question foundational tenets of their own faith?