Judge Suggested New Lawsuit for Citizenship Order Challenge
A federal judge indicated that new litigation is required to challenge President Donald Trump's latest birthright citizenship orders.
Updated on Sept. 22, 2026 in Immigration

Live Poll
Should the president have the authority to redefine birthright citizenship through executive orders?
Judge Joseph Normand Laplante suggested that the American Civil Liberties Union must file a new lawsuit to contest two executive orders issued by President Donald Trump. The orders aim to restrict birthright citizenship for specific groups, including children of parents associated with terrorist organizations or those involved in birth tourism.
Why it matters
The judge noted that these new orders target different classes of individuals than previous litigation, necessitating a fresh legal approach. This ruling impacts how civil rights groups may challenge executive actions that potentially conflict with established constitutional standards regarding birthright citizenship.
President Donald Trump issued two executive orders in August 2026 targeting children born to parents linked to terrorist organizations, birth tourism, or foreign diplomatic staff, as well as those born in U.S. territories. The U.S. Supreme Court has previously affirmed the constitutional right to birthright citizenship.
The players
Donald Trump
Donald Trump is the current President of the United States.
Joseph Normand Laplante
Joseph Normand Laplante is a federal judge who was nominated by former President George W. Bush.
American Civil Liberties Union
The American Civil Liberties Union is a non-profit organization focused on defending individual rights and liberties.
Deborah Boardman
Deborah Boardman is a federal judge based in Maryland who issued an injunction against the citizenship orders.
The details
The American Civil Liberties Union sought to expand an existing preliminary injunction against an initial 2025 order, but Judge Laplante determined that the new orders involve legally distinct categories. Meanwhile, Judge Deborah Boardman has already issued a separate preliminary injunction in Maryland blocking the enforcement of these same executive orders.
Timeline
President Donald Trump issued an initial executive order in 2025.
Two new executive orders on citizenship were issued in August 2026.
A preliminary injunction was issued in Maryland in September 2026.
Judge Joseph Normand Laplante held a hearing on the ACLU request on September 22, 2026.
Political Context
The administration's attempt to restrict citizenship via executive order stands in direct opposition to the constitutional right to birthright citizenship previously affirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court. Opponents argue that these measures bypass the legislative authority of Congress to alter citizenship requirements.
The potential enforcement of these executive orders could create significant legal uncertainty for families in U.S. territories like American Samoa. Residents and affected individuals should monitor for updates on the new lawsuit as the federal court system determines the scope of presidential authority in citizenship matters.
The takeaway
The court's insistence on a new lawsuit highlights the procedural complexities involved in challenging executive actions that define new legal classes. Citizens should remain aware that judicial rulings on birthright citizenship continue to shape the boundaries of constitutional law in the United States.
Further reading
For more on evolving federal policies, see our Immigration section.
Live Poll
Should the president have the authority to redefine birthright citizenship through executive orders?






