AM Best Downgraded A-CAP Group Credit Ratings
The rating agency slashed scores for Atlantic Coast Life and Sentinel Security Life amid balance sheet concerns.
Updated on Sept. 22, 2026 in Corporate Finance
Live Poll
Do you trust that insurance companies will fulfill their long-term financial commitments to policyholders?
AM Best has downgraded the credit ratings for A-CAP Group members, including Atlantic Coast Life Insurance Company and Sentinel Security Life Insurance Company. The action follows five consecutive quarters of negative operating gains and a weakened balance sheet.
Why it matters
The downgrade reflects concerns over the company's significant exposure to illiquid assets and ongoing reputational damage. Increased surrender levels and a pending rehabilitation petition in South Carolina have further pressured the group's financial stability.
A-CAP members saw their Financial Strength Rating lowered to C+ from B, while the Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating dropped to b- from bb+. The firm reported negative pretax operating gains for five consecutive quarters.
The players
AM Best
This global credit rating agency specializes in the insurance industry and evaluates the financial strength of insurance companies.
A-CAP Group
This holding company operates various insurance entities and manages assets for a diverse portfolio of clients.
South Carolina Department of Insurance
This state regulatory body oversees the insurance market in South Carolina and manages legal petitions regarding company solvency.
The details
A-CAP Group faces mounting pressure due to a heavy concentration of illiquid assets and thinly traded Level 3 securities. Publicized regulatory rulings have led to a decline in new premium intake and a surge in policy surrenders compared to 2024 levels.
Timeline
The deterioration of capital levels first emerged in 2024.
Surrenders remained elevated throughout Q1 2025 and reached peak multiples during H1 2025.
Capital levels and regulatory ratios saw marked deterioration during H1 2026.
AM Best announced the ratings downgrade on September 22, 2026.
Market Dynamics
The current downgrade follows a pattern set by the ongoing A-CAP Group rehabilitation petition, which signaled long-term structural instability in the firm's balance sheet. This development reflects broader industry challenges regarding liquidity management and the reliance on complex, unrated reinsurance.
Policyholders and investors should anticipate continued instability as the group navigates its current rehabilitation status. These shifts may impact the security of insurance products or the valuation of assets associated with the A-CAP Group.
The takeaway
The downgrade serves as a stark reminder of the risks associated with high concentrations of illiquid assets in insurance portfolios. Investors should closely monitor regulatory filings and solvency reports when assessing the stability of non-traditional insurance holdings.
What happens next
AM Best continues to monitor the development and impact of a potential capital raise and corporate restructuring for the group.
Further reading
For more on industry shifts, visit the Corporate Finance section.
Live Poll
Do you trust that insurance companies will fulfill their long-term financial commitments to policyholders?
