Reporter Removed From Hall of Fame Panel After Backlash

Mary Kay Cabot was removed from the Pro Football Hall of Fame voting panel following fan criticism.

Updated on Sept. 19, 2026 in Football

Reporter Removed From Hall of Fame Panel After Backlash

Live Poll

Do you find it appropriate for fans to publicly criticize reporters for their questioning style?

Reporter Mary Kay Cabot has been removed from the Pro Football Hall of Fame voting panel. The move follows public backlash regarding her questioning of Tampa Bay quarterback Baker Mayfield.

Why it matters

The decision to remove a voter highlights the influence of public pressure on professional sports media organizations and credentialed voting bodies. It underscores the tensions between reporters and fanbases when questions are perceived as overly critical.

Baker Mayfield currently holds a 72.6 PFN QB Impact score, ranking him No. 23 among qualifying quarterbacks. In the Week 1 loss to Cincinnati, he completed 23 of 28 passes for 216 yards and rushed for a touchdown, despite losing three fumbles.

The players

Mary Kay Cabot

She is a journalist who previously served as a voter for the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Baker Mayfield

He is an NFL quarterback currently playing for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Mike Rutenberg

He is a defensive coordinator who addressed media questions following the team's Week 1 performance.

The details

Mary Kay Cabot drew criticism after questioning defensive coordinator Mike Rutenberg about Mayfield's three lost fumbles during a media availability. Although Rutenberg initially praised Mayfield's competitive spirit, the follow-up inquiries sparked significant negative feedback from fans.

In 2018, the Cleveland Browns selected Baker Mayfield No. 1 overall in the NFL draft.
During Week 1 of the 2026 season, Mayfield lost three fumbles against the Cincinnati Bengals.
On September 18, 2026, reports confirmed the backlash and subsequent removal of the reporter.

Football
Sept. 20
Deshaun Watson Led Browns Past Buccaneers
Football
Sept. 19
Sixteen NFL Teams Faced Early Season Pressure
Football
Sept. 18
Mims Will Face Anderson in Week 2 Showdown

Season Trajectory

This development impacts the long-standing norms for media participation in league-sanctioned voting processes. It marks a shift in how professional organizations handle the intersection of fan sentiment and credentialed personnel.

Mayfield's current PFN QB Impact ranking of No. 23 reflects a volatile start to his 2026 campaign after his three-fumble performance. The loss to Cincinnati, ending 33-27, places increased scrutiny on his ball security as he continues the season.

The takeaway

Media members are increasingly subject to accountability measures when their questions draw significant ire from the public. Establishing professional boundaries remains essential for reporters operating within high-profile sports environments.