Court Weighs Saskatchewan CPP-at-60 Rule for Aid Recipients
The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal heard a constitutional challenge to rules requiring some social assistance recipients to start CPP at age 60.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should provinces be allowed to require early CPP withdrawal for disability assistance recipients?
The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal heard arguments on Monday in a constitutional challenge brought by the Regina Anti-Poverty Ministry to provincial rules requiring some social assistance recipients to begin Canada Pension Plan payments at age 60. The court reserved its decision, and the appeal follows a January 2025 Court of King's Bench ruling that dismissed the challenge.
Why it matters
Starting CPP before age 65 permanently reduces the monthly pension, and CPP income is deducted from provincial assistance between ages 60 and 65, so the rules directly affect how much income recipients have. The case also turns on whether the requirement is a constitutional question or a matter of public policy, as the provincial government contends.
Taking CPP at 60 instead of 65 cuts the pension by up to 36 per cent, according to the court record, and the Crown says 87 per cent of affected clients are better off while 13 per cent are harmed. The Court of Appeal's decision is pending and no timeline has been confirmed.
The players
Saskatchewan Government
The provincial government administers the SAID and SIS programs and maintains that the CPP-at-60 requirement is a matter of public policy rather than a legal issue.
Regina Anti-Poverty Ministry
A Regina-based advocacy organization that is challenging the provincial regulations in the Court of Appeal.
The details
Under Saskatchewan's Social Assistance Income Disability (SAID) and Saskatchewan Income Support (SIS) regulations, recipients must begin collecting CPP at age 60, and the appellant argues this is an unconstitutional requirement. In 2020 the Manitoba Court of Appeal ruled that a similar age-60 requirement for people with disabilities violated section 15 of the Charter, but in January 2025 Justice Colin Clackson dismissed the Saskatchewan challenge.
Timeline
January 2025: Court of King's Bench dismissed the Regina Anti-Poverty Ministry's challenge to the SAID and SIS regulations.
2020: Manitoba Court of Appeal ruled that requiring income assistance recipients with disabilities to apply for CPP at 60 violated the Charter.
November 16, 2026: Saskatchewan Court of Appeal heard arguments and reserved its decision.
Legal Context
The Manitoba Court of Appeal's 2020 ruling found an age-60 CPP requirement for disabled income assistance recipients violated section 15 of the Charter, yet a Saskatchewan trial judge dismissed a similar challenge in January 2025. The Saskatchewan appeal will determine whether the two provinces' courts reach a consistent answer on the question.
Recipients who start CPP at 60 receive a permanently smaller monthly pension, and the deduction from provincial assistance between ages 60 and 65 reduces the income they have available. The outcome of the appeal will determine whether this requirement continues for people receiving assistance in Saskatchewan.
The takeaway
Because CPP payments reduce provincial assistance between ages 60 and 65, anyone relying on social assistance should understand how early CPP uptake permanently lowers their pension before deciding when to start it. The appeal ruling will show whether Saskatchewan's approach holds up against the Manitoba precedent.
Further reading
For related court coverage, see the Law section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by SaskToday.
Live Poll
Should provinces be allowed to require early CPP withdrawal for disability assistance recipients?










