Ontario Physicians' College Won't Probe Powlowski

The college declined to investigate an MP over comments about medical assistance in dying, after a complaint was filed.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Law

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain stone institutional facade with a bare flagpole, in navy and cream with a muted red accent.
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario will not investigate MP Marcus Powlowski after Claire Brosseau filed a complaint over his remarks on medical assistance in dying. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should MPs face professional discipline for controversial comments about medical assistance in dying?

The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario is not investigating MP Marcus Powlowski, a physician, after Claire Brosseau filed a complaint over his comments about medical assistance in dying. A spokesperson did not say why the college is not pursuing an investigation.

Why it matters

The case raises questions about how a regulator treats a physician-MP's public remarks on a sensitive health policy, and about the limits of parliamentary freedom of speech. Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia has asked the law clerk to remind the college that members' speech is constitutionally protected.

The college's decision not to investigate followed a complaint by Claire Brosseau over Powlowski's supplementary opinion in a June report on medical assistance in dying. The college has not publicly explained its reasoning, and says it will review the Speaker's correspondence.

The players

Marcus Powlowski

Powlowski is a Liberal member of Parliament for Thunder Bay-Rainy River and a physician who made the remarks in question.

College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario

The college is the professional regulator responsible for licensing and disciplining physicians in Ontario.

Francis Scarpaleggia

Scarpaleggia is the Speaker of the House of Commons, who ruled that members' freedom of speech is constitutionally protected.

Claire Brosseau

Brosseau is the individual who filed the complaint against Powlowski over his comments on medical assistance in dying.

The details

In a supplementary opinion attached to a special joint committee report on medical assistance in dying, Powlowski wrote that other options exist for people seeking to end their lives, including illicit narcotics such as fentanyl. Brosseau said she was triggered by the comments, which she described as irresponsible, thoughtless and dangerous.

Timeline

  1. June 2026: Special joint committee report on medical assistance in dying published with Powlowski's supplementary opinion.

  2. Earlier the week of November 19, 2026: Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia asked the law clerk and parliamentary counsel to write to the college.

  3. November 19, 2026: Canadian Press reported that the college would not investigate.

Political Context

The Speaker's ruling rests on the constitutional protection of parliamentary speech, and the dispute tests whether a provincial professional regulator can scrutinize what a sitting MP says in the course of federal duties. The core counter-argument is that a physician's public comments on medical policy can still raise patient-safety concerns that a regulator must weigh.

For Ontario patients and physicians, the decision shows that a regulator may decline to act on a complaint about public statements by a physician acting as a politician. Anyone who wishes to challenge such a decision would need to pursue the college's own review or correspondence process.

The takeaway

Physicians who enter public life carry professional obligations alongside their parliamentary protections, and regulators and legislators are still working out where those lines fall. Readers following medical policy debates should watch for the college's response to the Speaker's correspondence.

Further reading

For background on the legal framework governing these disputes, see the Law section.

Live Poll

Should MPs face professional discipline for controversial comments about medical assistance in dying?