Julie Doiron's Broken Girl Ranks No. 43 on Pitchfork

Pitchfork placed Doiron's 1996 album among the 100 best indie rock albums of all time.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Alternative

Torn-edge indie rock poster illustration in hot pink and black with halftone dot texture and a single offset rectangular plane.
Pitchfork ranked Julie Doiron's 1996 album Broken Girl No. 43 on its list of the 100 best indie rock albums of all time. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Pitchfork ranked Julie Doiron's 1996 album Broken Girl at No. 43 on its list of the 100 best indie rock albums of all time. Doiron said she first saw the list the week before the article was published.

Why it matters

The ranking places a record made when Doiron was 21 alongside landmark indie releases such as Arcade Fire and Broken Social Scene. It also gives renewed attention to a Canadian album whose reissue drew a mixed reception from Pitchfork in 2003.

Broken Girl holds the No. 43 position among 100 albums on Pitchfork's list, and Pitchfork scored the 2003 reissue 5 out of 10. The extraction does not detail the list's full selection criteria.

The players

Julie Doiron

Doiron is a Canadian singer-songwriter from Moncton whose 1996 album Broken Girl is now ranked among Pitchfork's best indie rock albums.

Pitchfork

Pitchfork is an influential online music publication known for its album reviews and ranked lists of notable releases.

Sam Sodomsky

Sodomsky is a music writer who wrote the Pitchfork write-up that accompanies the album's placement on the list.

The details

Doiron wrote the songs for Broken Girl at 21, drawing on a breakup, new love, her pregnancy and her grandmother's illness. The track August 10 went viral about two years before the article was published, and the album was reissued in 2003.

Timeline

  1. 1996: Broken Girl is released.

  2. 2003: Broken Girl is reissued and reviewed by Pitchfork.

  3. About two years before publication: the track August 10 begins going viral.

  4. The week before publication: Doiron first sees the Pitchfork list.

Industry Dynamics

Pitchfork's canonical lists shape which independent records are remembered and revived, and Broken Girl's placement at No. 43 shows how older albums can gain renewed attention decades after release. The ranking also extends the reach of a record that Pitchfork rated only 5 out of 10 at its 2003 reissue.

Listeners interested in Broken Girl can seek out the album and its 2003 reissue through music retailers and streaming services. The Pitchfork ranking gives a starting point for finding other indie rock albums from the same era.

The takeaway

Older independent records can gain lasting recognition when critics revisit them, so exploring canonical lists can uncover albums that were overlooked on release. Checking a list's ranking alongside its written review can clarify why a record earned its place.

Further reading

Explore more on Alternative music coverage for context on indie rock's canon and its artists.

Source note: This article includes information reported by CBC News.