PCs Say Throne Speech Offers Little for Manitobans

Opposition MLA Josh Guenter called the NDP government's Throne Speech empty as the PCs released an alternate plan.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Taxes

PCs Say Throne Speech Offers Little for Manitobans

Live Poll

Are you better off today than you were three years ago?

Borderland PC MLA Josh Guenter criticized the NDP government's Throne Speech, titled 'Stronger Today, Stronger Tomorrow,' as empty. The PCs released an alternate throne speech proposing to raise the basic personal income tax threshold from $15,000 to $30,000.

Why it matters

The debate centres on how income tax policy, health care access and resource development affect household budgets and the province's economic competitiveness. Manitobans are being asked to weigh the government's record against the opposition's proposed alternative.

The NDP government collected an additional $82 million in income taxes last year after removing indexation, while the PC plan would lift the basic personal income tax threshold from $15,000 to $30,000. Whether the PC projection of about $3,000 in annual savings per average family would hold under the province's budget remains unaddressed.

The players

Josh Guenter

Josh Guenter is the Progressive Conservative MLA for the riding of Borderland in the Manitoba Legislative Assembly, serving as an opposition critic of the NDP government.

Manitoba NDP government

The New Democratic Party government is the governing administration of Manitoba, led by Premier Wab Kinew, and is responsible for the province's current Throne Speech and tax policy.

The details

The NDP government removed income tax indexation and eliminated the phase-out of the education property tax rebate. The PC alternative proposes doubling the basic personal income tax threshold and expanding what pharmacists can prescribe for several minor ailments, along with a Crown prosecutor's office dedicated to property crime.

Timeline

  1. Three years ago: A comparison point for judging whether Manitobans are better off.

  2. 2023: Manitoba ranked sixth most attractive jurisdiction in the world for mining under a PC government.

  3. Last summer: Winnipeg hospitals hit all-time highs for ER wait times.

  4. Last year: The NDP government collected an additional $82 million in income taxes after removing indexation.

  5. Next budget: A mega deduction for families is promised.

Tax Landscape

Removing income tax indexation lets inflation push more Manitobans into higher brackets over time, which the province collected $82 million from last year. The PC proposal to double the basic personal income tax threshold would reverse that effect for lower-income residents.

If the PC proposal were adopted, a basic personal income tax threshold of $30,000 would reduce taxes for lower-income Manitobans, with the opposition estimating savings of about $3,000 a year for an average family. Under the current structure without indexation, rising incomes can push taxpayers into higher brackets even when their purchasing power has not grown.

The takeaway

Tax thresholds and indexation rules directly determine how much of a paycheque Manitobans keep, so it is worth checking how the current and proposed rules would affect your own income bracket. Comparing both platforms' promises against the province's budget documents gives a clearer picture than either speech alone.

Further reading

For more on how provincial tax rules shape household budgets, see the Taxes section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by PembinaValleyOnline.

Live Poll

Are you better off today than you were three years ago?