TSB Renews Warning on Pre-2003 Railcar Wheels

A federal investigation links a 1992-built wheel failure to a February 2025 derailment near Emo, Ontario.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Auto Parts

Isometric editorial illustration of a single steel railcar wheel with a dark fracture line resting on a straight rail in a flat open corridor.
The Transportation Safety Board of Canada renewed its warning on pre-2003 railcar wheels after a 1992-built wheel shattered in a February 4, 2025 derailment near Emo, Ontario. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Transportation Safety Board of Canada reiterated concerns about railcar wheels manufactured before 2003 standards after its investigation report on the February 4, 2025 derailment near Emo, Ontario. The board determined a wheel manufactured in 1992 suffered a shattered rim failure linked to manufacturing imperfections.

Why it matters

The TSB investigated 14 broken-rim derailments between 2003 and 2025, and eight involved wheels made before the AAR steel cleanliness standards were introduced. The number of pre-2003 wheels still in service is unknown, and there is currently no proactive retirement strategy for them.

The failed wheel was manufactured in 1992 and exceeded imperfection limits under the AAR steel cleanliness standard introduced in 2003. The derailment occurred at minus-20 degrees Celsius with the train travelling about 42 mph when the emergency brake was applied.

The players

Transportation Safety Board of Canada

The TSB is Canada's independent federal agency that investigates transportation occurrences to advance safety and issues recommendations to prevent future accidents.

CN

Canadian National Railway is one of Canada's largest freight railways, operating across the country and into the United States.

The details

The R3 wheel on hopper CSXT 250514 dropped into gauge about two minutes before the emergency brake application, and examination found a large section of wheel tread was missing. A crack-containing wheel plate image showed the crack went undetected because the detector's image processing logic was not developed for cracked wheel detection.

Timeline

  1. April 2023: A CN derailment near Uncas, Alberta prompted a TSB system recommendation.

  2. February 3, 2025: A car passed a wheel profile detector at Stanberry, Wis., the day before the derailment.

  3. February 4, 2025: A train derailed near Emo, Ontario.

  4. November 17, 2026: The TSB released its investigation report on the Emo derailment.

Roadmap

The 2003 AAR steel cleanliness standard set a benchmark that pre-2003 wheels do not meet, and the TSB's findings show those older wheels remain a safety issue two decades later. The report signals that the industry has yet to fully address legacy equipment built before that benchmark.

Freight shipments carrying goods such as fertilizer depend on wheel safety, so older equipment still in service can affect delivery reliability and the cost of transporting goods. Industry operators may face pressure to inspect or retire pre-2003 wheels as the safety findings are considered.

The takeaway

Wheel age and manufacturing standards matter for rail safety, and older equipment deserves the same scrutiny as new. Monitoring investigation findings like these helps shippers and communities understand the risks tied to freight travelling through their regions.

Further reading

For more on component failures in vehicles and equipment, explore the Auto Parts section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Trains.