Insurance Industry Struggles to Keep New Advisors

Panelists at the Advocis Symposium said retaining new life insurance advisors is a bigger challenge than recruiting them.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Financial Planning

Insurance Industry Struggles to Keep New Advisors

Industry panelists at the Advocis Symposium in Toronto said the life insurance industry has a bigger problem retaining new advisors than attracting them. In 2023, only 20% of Canadian career-channel insurance advisors remained with their hiring firms after four years.

Why it matters

Commission-based pay leaves new advisors under financial pressure as they must prospect, find a niche and build a business at the same time. Captive agency channels that once offered training and some financial support have shrunk partly because of poor retention, leaving fewer structured paths into the profession for Canadians seeking financial advice careers.

Of Canadian career-channel insurance advisors, 20% remained with their hiring firms after four years in 2023. Onboarding a securities client can take less than 10 minutes, while completing a life insurance application can take nearly an hour, and the source does not explain how these durations affect retention.

The players

Advocis

Advocis is a Canadian professional association for financial advisors that hosts industry events and advocates for its members.

IPC

IPC is a Canadian investment dealer that uses a model of acquiring existing advisory books of business and hiring younger advisors to succeed them.

The details

Obtaining a life insurance licence is only the first step toward running a practice, and newer advisors often restrict themselves to a handful of carriers to limit administrative burden. The Professional Practice Initiative (PPI) connects newer advisors with established practices seeking additional capacity, geographic coverage or specialized expertise, and under one IPC model the dealer acquires an existing book of business and hires a younger advisor on salary to succeed the practice, with IPC handling much of the administrative work.

Timeline

  1. 2023: 20% of career-channel advisors remained with their hiring firms after four years.

  2. Thursday, before November 13, 2026: Advocis Symposium panel in Toronto discussed advisor retention.

Legacy Channels

Captive agency channels once provided training, education and some financial support to new insurance advisors, but they have diminished partly because of poor retention rates. The current retention problem reflects a structural shift in how Canadian life insurance advisors are trained and supported.

Consumers working with life insurance advisors may see changes in how advisors are supported and how long they remain in practice. Anyone considering a career in insurance should weigh the commission-based pay pressure and the need to build a client base while learning the profession.

The takeaway

Retention, not recruitment, is the constraint on building a stable life insurance advice workforce in Canada. Structured support models that pair new advisors with established practices may help more advisors stay the course.

Further reading

For broader context on career paths in the sector, explore Financial Planning coverage across Canada.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Investment Executive.