Independents File Complaint Over Ballot Paper Layout

Two independent Victorian upper house candidates say the ballot design discriminates against them by omitting their status above the line.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Politics

Independents File Complaint Over Ballot Paper Layout

Live Poll

Do you think independent candidates get a fair shot in Victorian elections?

Candidates Aleta Moriarty and Antoinette Pitt have lodged a complaint with the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission about how ballot papers present independent candidates. The Victorian Electoral Commission says no legal process exists for independent groups to register a name or logo for printing above the line.

Why it matters

Registered parties display their name and logo above the line, while independents receive only a blank box with no indication of their status. At the last state election, 9.52 per cent of formal votes were placed below the line, so presentation above the line can shape how voters read their options.

The figure of 9.52 per cent of formal votes placed below the line comes from the last state election, but the stub does not show how this compares with earlier elections. Whether the complaint will lead to any change in ballot design remains unresolved.

The players

Victorian Electoral Commission

The Victorian Electoral Commission is the state body responsible for conducting Victorian elections, including ballot paper design and candidate registration.

Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission

The Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission is the state body that investigates complaints of discrimination and breaches of human rights in Victoria.

The details

Aleta Moriarty, a Western Victoria upper house candidate, and Antoinette Pitt, an Eastern Victoria candidate, co-signed the complaint. The Victorian Electoral Commission allocates each group a letter and a box above the line, and says the printing process for names and logos is prescribed by the Electoral Act 2002.

Timeline

  1. Last state election: 9.52 per cent of formal votes were placed below the line.

  2. Article on the ballot presentation complaint published 18 November 2026.

  3. Proposed review and implementation of ballot presentation changes is expected before the next election.

Political Context

Independent candidates argue the ballot discriminates against them, while the Electoral Commission says printing rules are set by the Electoral Act 2002. The dispute reflects a broader question about whether the current design gives independents a fair presentation to voters.

Voters marking an upper house ballot may see independent candidates shown only as blank boxes above the line, without any indication of their status. Voters who wish to vote for an independent group should check the ballot carefully before marking it.

The takeaway

Ballot design can influence how voters read their options, and the outcome of this complaint may determine how independent candidates appear at future elections. Voters can review the ballot layout before polling day to understand how each group is shown.

Further reading

Explore more on the Elections section for context on how Victorian voting rules shape candidate presentation.

More information

Read the Victorian Electoral Commission upper house group registration information for how groups are registered and printed on the ballot.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Ferntree Gully Mail.

Live Poll

Do you think independent candidates get a fair shot in Victorian elections?