Court Rejects Old Treasury Challenge to Zen Energy Security

The NSW Supreme Court ruled that Zen Energy's new super senior debt security did not breach the terms of its 2023 loan note deed.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Debt Relief

Court Rejects Old Treasury Challenge to Zen Energy Security

The NSW Supreme Court rejected Old Treasury's bid to block a super senior debt security granted by Zen Energy. The court also ordered Old Treasury to pay the costs of the super senior security trustee.

Why it matters

The ruling clarifies how security and priority arrangements in corporate loan deeds are interpreted in New South Wales. It shows that lenders who do not sign onto a deed's consent provisions may have limited ability to challenge later security grants.

The governing threshold was lenders holding at least two-thirds of the debt, a figure set by the 2023 loan note deed that the court found had been satisfied. Whether Old Treasury will seek an appeal has not been reported.

The players

Old Treasury

Old Treasury is a lender that challenged the security granted to Zen Energy in the New South Wales Supreme Court.

Zen Energy

Zen Energy is an Australian energy company whose new super senior debt security was the subject of the court dispute.

The details

Old Treasury sought declarations that the new security breached the negative pledge in the 2023 loan note deed. The court held that accepting security under the deed's terms did not amend the deed, and that 'priority' referred to priority of payment, which had not changed. The priority deed gave the new facility first rank, and the court distinguished the uptier transaction in In Re Serta Simmons Bedding LLC because lenders there provided new money.

Timeline

  1. 2023: The loan note deed and the original facility were established.

Legal Context

The court distinguished this decision from the In Re Serta Simmons Bedding LLC uptier transaction, where lenders were involved in a similar restructuring. The ruling therefore turns on whether new money was provided, which separates it from the Serta line of cases.

For lenders and investors in corporate loan deeds, the ruling shows that consent and priority clauses may be enforced as written, so reviewing those provisions before committing funds matters. Parties not signing a subscription agreement may find they cannot enforce its sharing provisions.

The takeaway

Lenders should read consent and priority clauses closely, because courts may enforce them as written even when a later security grant is challenged. Protections not written into a deed may not be available to parties outside it.

Further reading

Explore more on debt relief to see how secured lending disputes like this one can affect borrowers and creditors.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Australasian Lawyer.