Full Court Rejects ASIC Appeal Against Former Director
The Full Federal Court upheld the dismissal of civil penalty proceedings against a former director of the deregistered insurer Freedom Insurance.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Financial Crime

Live Poll
Do you trust insurance companies to put customers ahead of sales targets?
The Full Federal Court dismissed the Australian Securities and Investments Commission's appeal against the earlier dismissal of its civil penalty proceedings against a former director of Freedom Insurance. The Court also agreed that the insurer's incentive programmes constituted conflicted remuneration under the Corporations Act 2001.
Why it matters
The ruling confirms that the incentive arrangements at Freedom Insurance amounted to conflicted remuneration, a finding relevant to how insurers structure sales rewards. The decision also leaves the individual claims against the former director dismissed, shaping how ASIC pursues similar cases.
The Full Federal Court heard ASIC's appeal on 26 and 27 August 2026 and has rejected it, upholding the 16 October 2025 Federal Court dismissal of claims against the former director. ASIC withdrew its separate appeal concerning a former insurance consultant by consent on 19 December 2025, and the source does not indicate whether further appeal steps are open.
The players
Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)
ASIC is Australia's national corporate, markets and financial services regulator, responsible for enforcing the Corporations Act 2001.
Freedom Insurance
Freedom Insurance was an Australian insurer that was deregistered and whose parent Freedom Group entered external administration in February 2020.
The details
ASIC launched civil penalty proceedings in October 2021 over incentive programmes run by the Freedom Group between November 2017 and October 2018, which included trips to Bali and a Vespa scooter for top-performing agents. ASIC alleged the arrangements encouraged staff to prioritise policy sales over customers' interests, but the Full Court upheld the earlier dismissal of the claims against the former director.
Timeline
November 2017 to October 2018: Freedom Group incentive programmes operated.
February 2020: The Freedom Group entered external administration.
October 2021: ASIC launched civil penalty proceedings against the two individuals.
16 October 2025: The Federal Court dismissed ASIC's claims against both individuals.
26 and 27 August 2026: The Full Federal Court heard the appeal.
Legal Context
The Full Court's reading of the conflicted remuneration provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 sets a clear test for sales incentives in financial services. The outcome shows that establishing liability for individual directors remains difficult even where the underlying incentive arrangements are found to be conflicted.
Customers of insurers that offer sales incentives may be affected by how those arrangements are structured, since the Full Court found such incentives can amount to conflicted remuneration. Policyholders dealing with insurers should be aware that regulators must prove individual liability, which the ASIC case did not establish against the former director.
The takeaway
Sales incentives that reward volume can create conflicts with customer interests, and their structure matters under the Corporations Act 2001. Readers reviewing insurance products may wish to ask how advisers and agents are paid.
Further reading
For related coverage, see Financial Crime reporting on Australian regulatory enforcement.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Insurance Business.
Live Poll
Do you trust insurance companies to put customers ahead of sales targets?










