Court Rules Psychologist's Report Covered by Privilege

A Federal Court decision confirms that legal professional privilege can protect a psychologist's medical examination report in civil proceedings.

Updated on Nov. 9, 2026 in Politics

Isometric editorial illustration of a brass padlock resting beside a closed folder on a walnut desk, in oxblood, teal, and cream.
The Federal Court ruled that legal professional privilege can protect a psychologist's medical examination report, with that protection waived once the report is relied upon in proceedings. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Federal Court has ruled that legal professional privilege covers a psychologist's medical examination report. Privilege would be waived once the report is filed in the proceeding.

Why it matters

The ruling clarifies how parties can obtain medical examinations of opposing parties while keeping expert advice protected. It shapes how litigants in Australia approach expert evidence before deciding whether to rely on it.

The court ordered the plaintiff to pay two parties' costs on 23 December 2025 over interlocutory document requests involving legal professional privilege. Rules 23.21(2)-(5) of the Federal Court Rules allow a medical examination without an interlocutory application, but the necessity must be shown.

The players

Federal Court of Australia

The federal court that heard the matter and issued the ruling on privilege and costs.

The details

The respondents agreed to provide the applicant with a copy of the psychologist's report if they relied on it, and the court did not require the report to be obtained and served. The court accepted that the respondents' solicitor could draw on the psychologist's findings to advise on the conduct of the proceeding.

Timeline

  1. 23 December 2025: Federal Court ordered the plaintiff to pay two parties' costs over privilege-related document requests.

Legal Context

The decision applies the medical examination provisions of Rules 23.21 of the Federal Court Rules, which require a party to show necessity before an opposing party is examined while the expert's advice stays privileged. It reflects how Australian courts balance disclosure obligations against the protection of legal advice.

Parties in Federal Court proceedings may face medical examinations of opposing parties and must weigh whether to rely on expert reports, since reliance can waive privilege. Costs can follow disputes over privileged document requests.

The takeaway

Parties who rely on expert reports should expect those reports to be disclosed once they are filed. Privilege protects the advice taken from them until that point.

Further reading

Explore more Law news for context on how courts treat privilege and expert evidence.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Australasian Lawyer.