Ombudsman Probes Faulty Aged Care Assessment Tool

A new investigation reveals flaws in the system determining service levels for over one million Australians.

Updated on Oct. 26, 2026 in Alternative Medicine

Bold flat-color editorial illustration featuring stacked geometric blocks, representing the rigid structure of a bureaucratic algorithmic assessment system. — The Commonwealth Ombudsman has launched an investigation into flaws within the Australian government's integrated aged care assessment algorithm, which currently lacks transparency. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust the government to be transparent about how automated systems decide your public services?

The Commonwealth Ombudsman has released a report highlighting critical issues with the Department of Health, Disability and Ageing's Integrated Assessment Tool. The automated algorithm determines aged care service levels for 1.1 million Australians but lacks necessary transparency and human override functions.

Why it matters

The investigation revealed that the system fails to provide safeguards or allow for the correction of clinically inappropriate assessments. These systemic failures pose significant risks to elderly individuals relying on home support who may be assigned incorrect care levels due to opaque algorithmic decisions.

The Commonwealth Ombudsman issued 10 recommendations to address deficiencies within the Department of Health, Disability and Ageing. Assessment providers are currently failing to meet established key performance indicators while using this automated system.

The players

Commonwealth Ombudsman

This independent office investigates complaints about the administrative actions of Australian government departments and agencies.

Department of Health, Disability and Ageing

This federal agency is responsible for developing and implementing policies and programs related to health and aged care in Australia.

The details

The Integrated Assessment Tool, introduced in November 2025, currently makes automated decisions that cannot be overridden by staff under existing law. The department previously provided incorrect information to providers and the public, suggesting that outcomes could be manually adjusted until October 2025.

1 November 2025: Implementation of the Integrated Assessment Tool.
October 2025: End of incorrect department advice regarding override capability.
September 2026: Media reports of staff warnings to ministers.
26 October 2026: Publication of the Ombudsman investigation report.

Health Landscape

This investigation exposes a gap between the reliance on automated algorithmic tools and the regulatory requirements of the Australian Aged Care Act. It marks a departure from standard assessment practices by removing the ability for clinical professionals to override automated service determinations.

Australians currently accessing home support services may need to monitor their care assessments more closely following these revelations of system errors. If you believe your assigned service level is clinically inappropriate, you should contact your provider to discuss how to register a formal inquiry.

The takeaway

Transparency remains a critical hurdle when government agencies adopt automated decision-making processes for essential public services. Families should proactively review their assessment outcomes to ensure they reflect the actual care needs of the individual.