Davidson Sends Montoya to Sin Bin in Paris

Scottish referee Hollie Davidson penalised Argentina captain Julian Montoya for going off his feet during France's rugby match against Argentina in Paris.

Updated on Nov. 22, 2026 in Other Sports

Expressive editorial sports illustration of two rugby players in blue and white contesting a loose ball at a breakdown, with a referee in black stepping in.
France led Argentina 26-10 in Paris when referee Hollie Davidson sent Argentina captain Julian Montoya to the sin bin for going off his feet at the breakdown. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Hollie Davidson refereed France's rugby match against Argentina in Paris, where she penalised Argentina captain Julian Montoya for going off his feet at the breakdown and sent him to the sin bin. The decision came while France led 26-10.

Why it matters

The penalty decision removed Argentina's captain from play during a match between two leading international rugby sides. Davidson's handling of a high-profile men's fixture draws attention to the growing role she has played in officiating prominent international rugby.

The match score stood at 26-10 in France's favour when the penalty was awarded against Argentina captain Julian Montoya. The source does not state the final score or how long Montoya remained in the sin bin.

The players

Hollie Davidson

Scottish rugby referee, aged 33, who has refereed increasingly prominent men's international rugby matches.

Julian Montoya

Argentina rugby captain who was sent to the sin bin during the match against France.

Will Carling

Former England rugby captain who publicly praised Davidson's refereeing on X.

The details

During the match, Louis Bielle-Biarrey flew into the breakdown and Montoya attempted to steal possession. Davidson told Montoya, 'Off feet, you're driving over the breakdown,' before sending him to the sin bin for the offence.

Timeline

  1. November 2026: France versus Argentina match is played in Paris.

Season Trajectory

Davidson's appointment to a France-Argentina test extends a trend of women referees being given increasingly prominent men's international rugby fixtures. Her handling of the match adds to the record of women officiating at the highest level of the men's game.

Fans following Argentina's rugby team will want to note that Montoya was sent to the sin bin during the match. The source does not report whether Montoya was able to return to play before the match ended.

The takeaway

Referee decisions at the breakdown, such as the penalty against Montoya for going off his feet, can change the course of a match and draw scrutiny from players and former players alike. Watching how officials explain their calls to players offers a clearer view of how these decisions are made.

Further reading

For more context on rugby and other international competitions, explore Other Sports.

Source note: This article includes information reported by WalesOnline.