Jeff Cobb Recalls Rejecting WWE Offers Before NJPW
The former WWE performer described turning down the company's contract offers in a 2021 interview before later signing with New Japan Pro-Wrestling.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Wrestling

Jeff Cobb, formerly known as JC Mateo in WWE, said he turned down contract offers from the company after a 2021 video interview with a former WWE talent development executive. Cobb later signed a three-year deal with New Japan Pro-Wrestling and joined the promotion in 2025.
Why it matters
Cobb's account offers a firsthand look at how a performer weighed a WWE offer against other options during the pandemic era. It also shows how one interview with company staff can influence whether a talent accepts a contract.
Cobb's NJPW deal runs three years, and he described NXT at the time as having three pay tiers. The account comes from his own recollection, and WWE's offer terms were not disclosed.
The players
Jeff Cobb
Jeff Cobb is a professional wrestler who previously performed in WWE under the name JC Mateo and later worked with New Japan Pro-Wrestling.
New Japan Pro-Wrestling
New Japan Pro-Wrestling is a Japanese professional wrestling promotion and one of the largest wrestling companies in Japan.
The details
Cobb spoke with Chris Van Vliet on the Insight podcast about being approached by WWE in 2020 after his AEW match with Jon Moxley. He said he turned down the company again after a 2021 video interview in which a former WWE talent development executive, who was in bed during the call, described pay practices and said WWE paid its talent during the pandemic. Cobb said both the executive's demeanor and that comment factored into his decision.
Timeline
2020: WWE first approached Cobb following his match with Jon Moxley in AEW.
2021: Cobb turned down WWE after a video interview with a former WWE talent development executive.
2025: Cobb joined New Japan Pro-Wrestling after signing a three-year deal.
Season Trajectory
Cobb's decision to turn down WWE and later sign with New Japan reflects the competition among major wrestling promotions for top performers. It adds a firsthand example of how talent choices shape the balance between WWE, AEW and Japanese promotions.
For fans tracking NJPW's roster, Cobb's three-year deal sets his timeline with the promotion. Viewers following his career can use that contract length to gauge when his next major move might arrive.
The takeaway
Talent decisions in pro wrestling often hinge on how a company treats performers during hard periods and how it presents its offers. Fans and reporters can learn from Cobb's account how those factors shape career paths.
Further reading
Explore more Wrestling coverage for context on how promotions compete for talent.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Wrestling Inc..



