EU Court Adviser Says Facebook Users Pay With Data
An EU Advocate General finds Facebook's "free" service is paid for through personal data under unfair advertising rules.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Internet

Live Poll
Do you trust social media companies when they say their services are free?
EU Advocate General Laila Medina found that Facebook users pay for the service by handing over personal data, in a case brought by the Federation of German Consumer Organizations against Meta Platforms Ireland over its "Facebook is and remains free" slogan. Meta has since dropped the slogan from its German-language sign-up page and said it respectfully disagrees with the opinion.
Why it matters
The opinion bears on whether a free-looking digital service can be marketed as free when users must grant permission for commercial use of their data. The EU judges' eventual ruling will set the binding answer on what counts as payment, which could shape how platforms advertise to consumers across the bloc.
The key timeline runs from the slogan's appearance in February 2015 to the German court's September 2025 referral to EU judges. The binding answer on what counts as payment has not yet been issued.
The players
Meta Platforms Ireland
The Irish subsidiary of Meta Platforms, the parent company behind Facebook, which operates the service for European users. It is the defendant in the German consumer lawsuit over the "free" slogan.
Laila Medina
The EU Advocate General who issued the advisory opinion finding that Facebook users pay with their personal data. Advocates General provide non-binding opinions that guide the EU Court of Justice.
Federation of German Consumer Organizations
A German consumer advocacy group that sued Meta to stop the use of the "Facebook is and remains free" slogan with German consumers.
The details
Facebook required users to share data and grant permission for its commercial use before signing up, and used that data to build user profiles and sell targeted ads. Two Berlin courts sided with Facebook before the Federal Court of Justice paused the case to seek guidance from EU judges.
Timeline
February 2015: Facebook's German sign-up page displays the "free" slogan.
September 2025: Germany's top court pauses the case and refers the question to the EU.
November 19, 2026: Advocate General Laila Medina issues her advisory opinion.
Big Picture
The opinion applies the EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive to a free-service claim, extending its misleading-advertising rules to data-funded digital platforms. It positions the case as a test of whether personal data counts as payment under that framework.
Users who sign up for free platforms should understand that granting data-use permission can be the price of access. The opinion suggests European consumers may see clearer disclosures about what they give up when signing up for "free" services.
The takeaway
Free online services often carry a data cost that is not always visible at sign-up, so reviewing what permissions you grant before creating an account is a practical step. The forthcoming EU ruling may clarify how such costs must be disclosed.
What happens next
The EU Court of Justice is expected to issue the binding ruling on what counts as payment, after which Germany's top court will decide whether Meta can revive its "free" promise.
Further reading
For more on how online platforms make money from user data, see our Internet coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Court House News Service.
Live Poll
Do you trust social media companies when they say their services are free?



