Authors Argue De-Extinction Cannot Revive Lost Species
A Biology Letters article contends that rebuilding an extinct genome does not restore the lineage it came from.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Life Sciences

Live Poll
Should scientists prioritize saving endangered animals over bringing back extinct species?
Wheaton College researchers Andrew Davinack and Charlotte K. Daniels published an article in the journal Biology Letters arguing that de-extinction cannot bring back extinct species. The authors respond to Colossal Biosciences' April 2025 announcement of three genetically modified gray wolf pups presented as the return of the dire wolf.
Why it matters
The authors argue that equating a reconstructed genome with a revived lineage leads some companies to claim de-extinction is possible. Their position challenges how the science and its promises are presented to the public.
The argument rests on a comparison of genome differences, with a dire wolf genome showing millions of differences from a gray wolf genome, against Colossal's animals carrying 20 gene edits. Whether these figures support or undercut the claim of a revived species is not resolved in the source.
The players
Colossal Biosciences
A de-extinction company that has also pursued projects to bring back the woolly mammoth and the giant moa, and works on genetic diversity for the American red wolf and black-footed ferret.
Andrew Davinack
A marine biologist at Wheaton College and co-author of the Biology Letters article critiquing de-extinction claims.
Charlotte K. Daniels
A biochemist and co-author of the Biology Letters article arguing that reconstructed genomes do not restore extinct lineages.
The details
Davinack and Daniels argue that species are historically continuous population-level lineages shaped by gene flow, mutation, drift, selection, demographic history and ecological interaction, not just a set of genes. Colossal's April 2025 pups, named Romulus, Remus and Khaleesi, are genetically modified gray wolves, which the authors say cannot constitute the extinct lineage.
Timeline
April 2025: Colossal Biosciences announces the return of the dire wolf via three genetically modified pups.
November 19, 2026: The Biology Letters article arguing de-extinction is impossible is published.
Big Picture
The debate centers on Colossal Biosciences' April 2025 dire wolf announcement, which framed three genetically modified gray wolves as a return of an animal absent from North America for about 10,000 years. The Biology Letters article pushes back on that framing by arguing that a rebuilt genome does not recreate a continuous species lineage.
The argument affects how readers should weigh headlines claiming extinct animals have returned, since a genetically edited animal may differ substantially from the original species. Readers evaluating conservation or biotech news can use the distinction between a reconstructed genome and a continuous lineage as a check on such claims.
The takeaway
A genome reconstruction is not automatically a revived species, so claims of de-extinction deserve scrutiny of what exactly has been restored. Evaluating those claims means asking whether the animal is part of the continuous population lineage it claims to represent.
Further reading
Explore more on Life Sciences to see how genetics and species research shape debates like this one.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Popular Mechanics.
Live Poll
Should scientists prioritize saving endangered animals over bringing back extinct species?



