Germany, U.K. Push Back on U.S. Ukraine Strike Criticism

Berlin and London defended Ukraine's deep strike campaign inside Russia after U.S. Undersecretary of Defense Elbridge Colby questioned its effectiveness.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Military

Germany, U.K. Push Back on U.S. Ukraine Strike Criticism

Live Poll

Should the U.S. stop criticizing Ukraine's strikes inside Russia?

Germany and the U.K. pushed back against U.S. criticism of Ukraine's deep strike campaign inside Russia. Speaking at NATO headquarters in Belgium on Tuesday, Undersecretary of Defense Elbridge Colby said the strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war or blunting Russia's advances.

Why it matters

The dispute exposes a divide among Western allies over how to pressure Moscow after more than 4½ years of conflict. Ukraine's strikes on Russian oil facilities and logistics infrastructure are central to how the war's costs are being weighed.

Ukraine's Armed Forces gained more territory than Russia for the second consecutive month in October, according to the figures cited in the report. The size of the gains and how much they reflect the deep strike campaign remain unclear.

The players

Elbridge Colby

U.S. Undersecretary of Defense who has argued for a sharper focus on deterring China and reducing U.S. commitments in Europe.

Wildberries

Russia's largest online retailer, which Colby cited as a civilian target and which denies involvement in the war in Ukraine.

The details

Colby acknowledged that Ukraine's mid-range strike campaign using novel drone technologies has proven very effective, but argued the deep strikes on civilian infrastructure have hardened Russian public resolve, citing Russia's biggest online retailer, Wildberries. Kyiv says warehouses targeted by Ukrainian drones supplied Russian forces with drone components and navigation equipment, a claim Wildberries and the Kremlin deny.

Timeline

  1. Tuesday (November 17, 2026): Colby spoke at NATO headquarters in Belgium, and Germany and the U.K. responded.

  2. October 2026: Ukraine gained more territory than Russia for the second consecutive month.

  3. Thursday (November 19, 2026): Trump, Putin and Xi are scheduled to meet in Shenzhen, China.

Military Context

The deep strike campaign extends the logistics-targeting approach Ukraine used in its 2022 Kharkiv and Kherson counteroffensives, now aimed deeper inside Russia. Allied debate over its value reflects whether such strikes change Moscow's calculations or only harden public opinion.

Disagreement over the deep strikes could shape how Western governments weigh support for Ukraine's long-range campaign against Russian oil and logistics targets. For readers, the outcome affects energy markets and the pace at which the war's costs accumulate for both sides.

The takeaway

Battlefield success and strategic effect are not the same thing, and Western allies are still debating which of Ukraine's strikes actually move the war toward an end. Watch how the Shenzhen talks treat Ukraine's campaign if it comes up in those discussions.

What happens next

The Trump, Putin and Xi meeting in Shenzhen on Thursday (November 19, 2026) is expected to address geopolitical flashpoints including trade, artificial intelligence and nuclear weapons.

Further reading

For broader context on troop movements and battlefield developments, see the Military section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by CNBC.

Live Poll

Should the U.S. stop criticizing Ukraine's strikes inside Russia?