Online Discussions Grow More Negative Over Time
A PNAS study of 2.05 billion Reddit comments links differentiation-seeking behavior to a steady drop in positivity.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Social Sciences

Live Poll
Do you find online discussions get more negative the longer they go on?
Researchers analyzing 2.05 billion comments from 2,150 Reddit communities found that discourse becomes less positive as a topic is discussed longer. Conversations that start out more positively tend to turn more negative over time, according to a paper published in PNAS.
Why it matters
The findings suggest that the tone of online debate may be shaped by structural dynamics rather than solely by individual temperament. Understanding this pattern could help platform designers and communities anticipate how positive conversations erode.
The analysis covered 2.05 billion comments from 2,150 Reddit communities, a sample drawn from a single platform. The paper's causal explanation for the pattern is a theory supported by the observed trends rather than a directly measured mechanism.
The players
Joshua Conrad Jackson
Joshua Conrad Jackson is an Assistant Professor of Psychiatry at Harvard who co-authored the study on differentiation and negativity in online discussions.
The details
The theory holds that posters differentiate themselves by picking apart elements of popular media that no one has commented on before. Commenters seeking to stand out run out of ways to repeat positive remarks once a topic is widely praised, and negative remarks offer more room for distinction.
Timeline
Article on the PNAS differentiation study published November 16, 2026.
Big Picture
The study adds a time-based dimension to the large-scale computational research published in PNAS on how online conversations evolve. It points to a possible structural explanation for negativity that complements accounts focused on individual behavior.
Readers who participate in long-running online threads or fandom forums may notice the shift toward negativity the study describes. Some online spaces such as fandom forums may be especially vulnerable to the proposed effect.
The takeaway
Conversations that begin positively may drift toward criticism as they continue, partly because differentiation-seeking commenters exhaust praise. Recognizing this pattern can help readers evaluate tone shifts in long online discussions.
Further reading
Explore more research in the Social Sciences section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by HuffPost UK.
Live Poll
Do you find online discussions get more negative the longer they go on?







