Carbon Markets Risk Repeating Colonial Land Control

Indigenous representatives at COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, warned that carbon trading schemes could reinforce colonial land systems.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Native American

Carbon Markets Risk Repeating Colonial Land Control

Live Poll

Do you trust carbon offset programs to genuinely reduce pollution?

Indigenous representatives warned at a COP31 side event in Antalya, Turkey, that carbon trading schemes risk reinforcing colonial land systems. Panelists urged governments to prioritize Indigenous-led climate finance and protect customary land tenure.

Why it matters

Carbon markets under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement value nature mainly for its carbon-storage capacity, overlooking the social, cultural and spiritual ties Indigenous peoples have to their lands. Critics say carbon offsets let major polluters buy credits instead of cutting emissions.

Research cited at the event found more than 90% of certain voluntary carbon credits to be phantom credits, while some long-term carbon agreements run up to 30 years. The wider market share affected by such credits was not established in the source.

The players

COP31

The 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference, the annual global summit where countries negotiate responses to climate change.

The details

Speakers said carbon-credit projects in Tanzania penalize livestock movements of pastoralist groups including the Maasai, and that women lack direct access to carbon revenues. They also pointed to Kenya's recent changes to national climate governance, which removed criteria for Indigenous representation on the National Council on Climate Change.

Timeline

  1. Event held at COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, on November 12, 2026.

Season Trajectory

Article 6 of the Paris Agreement sets the framework for international carbon markets, and this critique challenges whether those markets treat Indigenous land as a storage asset rather than a living system. The debate is likely to shape how governments design carbon finance rules heading into future climate negotiations.

Carbon-credit projects can restrict how pastoralist communities move their livestock and can leave women without direct access to the revenue these projects generate. Changes to who sits on national climate councils can also determine whether Indigenous communities have a voice in climate decisions that affect their land.

The takeaway

Climate finance that ignores land tenure and community consent can shift costs and control onto Indigenous and pastoralist communities. Readers following carbon policy should ask who holds the land rights behind any offset project.

Further reading

For more on Indigenous perspectives on land and culture, explore our Native American coverage.

Live Poll

Do you trust carbon offset programs to genuinely reduce pollution?