Revised Carbon Data Reshapes Beta Pictoris b Origin
New GRAVITY+ observations contradict an earlier measurement and suggest the giant planet may have formed differently than previously thought.
Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Space

Researchers using GRAVITY+ at the Very Large Telescope Interferometer in Chile revised the 12CO/13CO ratio of Beta Pictoris b, reported in Astronomy & Astrophysics on 9 July 2026. The new, substantially higher ratio disagrees with an earlier GRAVITY measurement that placed the planet's formation beyond the carbon monoxide snowline.
Why it matters
Carbon isotope ratios are used to infer where giant planets formed within their disks, so the revision directly affects how astronomers reconstruct planetary origins. The new value agrees with independent measurements, suggesting the earlier result may have been affected by instrumental limitations.
The revised measurement rests on GRAVITY+ interferometry of Beta Pictoris b, a planet roughly 11 times Jupiter's mass orbiting about 10 astronomical units from its star. The brightness variations with an 8.7-hour period are tentative, and their origin has not been established.
The players
Very Large Telescope Interferometer
An interferometric array operated by the European Southern Observatory in Chile that combines light from multiple telescopes to achieve high angular resolution.
GRAVITY+
An upgraded instrument at the Very Large Telescope Interferometer used to resolve and analyze the atmosphere of exoplanets such as Beta Pictoris b.
European Southern Observatory
An intergovernmental astronomical organization that operates major ground-based telescope facilities, including the Very Large Telescope in Chile.
The details
Astronomers infer planetary formation locations by comparing the relative abundance of two forms of carbon monoxide, which depends on the snowline where CO freezes onto dust grains. The revised measurement points to a different formation history than the earlier GRAVITY result, which may have been affected by instrumental limitations. Researchers say more precise observations and additional chemical indicators will be needed to reconstruct the planet's origins.
Timeline
9 July 2026: Study published in Astronomy & Astrophysics reporting the revised carbon isotope ratio for Beta Pictoris b.
Deeper Dive
The revision updates a 12CO/13CO figure first reported by the earlier GRAVITY measurements of Beta Pictoris b, which had suggested the planet formed beyond the snowline. Similar carbon isotope values have now been measured in most of roughly a dozen young giant planets studied with this technique.
Carbon isotope methods like this one shape how astronomers reconstruct the formation of giant planets, which in turn informs models of how solar systems assemble. More sensitive observations could eventually refine these models for planets beyond Beta Pictoris b.
The takeaway
Revised measurements can overturn earlier conclusions, and cross-checking with independent data is how astronomers separate instrumental artifacts from real planetary chemistry. The planet's formation story is still being refined as new observations arrive.
Further reading
Explore more space discoveries on exoplanets and planetary system formation.



