Cloudflare Ends Merkle Tree Certificate Experiment

Cloudflare wound down its test of Merkle Tree Certificates with Chrome Beta users in August 2026, after measuring a 9% performance gain.

Updated on Nov. 9, 2026 in Quantum Computing

Cloudflare Ends Merkle Tree Certificate Experiment

In August 2026, Cloudflare wound down an experiment serving Merkle Tree Certificates to 50% of Chrome Beta 146 users on selected domains on its free plan. The test used classical signatures and reported a 9% faster median performance.

Why it matters

The experiment tested an alternative to traditional certificate chains as the web's public key infrastructure faces scaling pressure from post-quantum cryptography. Post-quantum signatures can be approximately 40 times larger than classical signatures, making efficiency gains a central concern.

The experiment measured a 9% faster median performance in Chrome Beta 146, with 50% of users receiving certificates, and post-quantum signatures run about 40 times larger than classical ones. Cloudflare attributed most of the gain to eliminating intermediate certificates, while the full impact on post-quantum deployment remains unclear.

The players

Cloudflare

Cloudflare is a major internet infrastructure company that operates content delivery and security services across much of the web.

Google Chrome

Google Chrome is the most widely used web browser, and its Root Store determines which certificate authorities browsers trust.

The details

Cloudflare tested Merkle Tree Certificates, which record certificate data in an append-only Merkle tree and sign a checkpoint, letting clients verify inclusion with cryptographic proofs. An independent mirroring cosigner verifies and stores updated tree states, and Cloudflare used the ACME protocol to validate domain ownership.

Timeline

  1. August 2026: Cloudflare wound down the Merkle Tree Certificate experiment with Chrome Beta users.

  2. Early 2027: Cloudflare targets inclusion of its public certificate authority in Chrome's quantum-resistant Root Store, subject to evaluation.

The Tech Race

Merkle Tree Certificates offer a way to shrink the certificate chains that post-quantum signatures would otherwise make far larger, as Cloudflare's Chrome Beta test with a 9% median speedup illustrates. Cloudflare's targeted early-2027 inclusion in Chrome's quantum-resistant Root Store would test whether the approach can move from experiment to standard practice.

Users of Chrome may see faster certificate validation if the approach reaches general release, since the test measured a 9% median speedup. Post-quantum signatures are much larger than classical ones, so efficiency gains like these could affect page load times as the web migrates.

The takeaway

Efficiency work on certificate design now runs in parallel with the post-quantum transition, not after it. Readers following web security should watch whether Chrome's Root Store evaluation in early 2027 turns this experiment into a standard.

What happens next

Cloudflare targets inclusion of its public certificate authority in Chrome's quantum-resistant Root Store in early 2027, subject to evaluation.

Further reading

For more on the cryptographic groundwork behind this test, see Quantum Computing.

Source note: This article includes information reported by InfoQ.