Napoleon Grills Top Consumer Reports Rankings
The brand secured the number one spot across small, midsized, and large gas grill categories in new testing.
Updated on Oct. 31, 2026 in Barbecue
Live Poll
When buying a grill, do you prioritize expert performance ratings over established brand reputation?
Consumer Reports ranked Napoleon as the top-performing gas grill brand across three size categories. The Napoleon Rogue PRO 425, Rogue PRO 625, and Freestyle 365 all placed first in their respective segments.
Why it matters
The rankings highlight how specific performance factors like indirect cooking ability distinguish top-rated models in a competitive market. These results help consumers prioritize technical features when evaluating premium outdoor cooking equipment.
The Napoleon Rogue PRO 425 costs $1,079, while competitive Weber Genesis II models are priced at $899 and $979. Napoleon grills outperformed competitors specifically in testing for temperature range and even heat distribution.
The players
Napoleon
Napoleon is a global manufacturer of premium gas grills and outdoor cooking equipment.
Consumer Reports
Consumer Reports is an independent non-profit organization that provides expert reviews and product testing.
Weber
Weber is a well-known manufacturer of grills and barbecue accessories.
The details
Testers evaluated grills based on preheating speed, even heat distribution, and temperature range. Indirect cooking performance proved to be a primary factor that helped Napoleon models secure the top ranking over Weber, which holds the third through sixth spots in the midsized category.
Timeline
October 31, 2026: Article published regarding gas grill rankings.
Culture Shift
This ranking reflects a broader shift toward premium outdoor appliances as consumers demand professional-grade performance in residential settings. The trend favors brands that emphasize heat precision and specialized cooking capabilities over legacy market dominance.
Shoppers may need to weigh the higher price point of Napoleon models, such as the $1,079 Rogue PRO 425, against the performance benefits they provide over lower-cost alternatives. Buyers should consider their specific indirect cooking needs when comparing these top-rated models to existing Weber options.
The takeaway
When choosing a new grill, focus on the specific heat management features that match your cooking style rather than brand name alone. Prioritize models that excel in both preheating speed and indirect heat if you regularly prepare roasts or slow-cooked items.
Further reading
For more information on product evaluations and trends, visit our Barbecue section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Takeout.
Live Poll
When buying a grill, do you prioritize expert performance ratings over established brand reputation?
