Erik ten Hag Criticizes McTominay Transfer Sale
The former Manchester United manager reflects on the 2024 decision to sell the academy product to Napoli.
Updated on Oct. 20, 2026 in Soccer
Live Poll
Should sports clubs prioritize financial goals over retaining players who have long histories with the team?
In 2024, Manchester United sold long-time academy product Scott McTominay to Napoli for £25 million. Former manager Erik ten Hag recently expressed his embarrassment regarding the club's decision to offload the player.
Why it matters
Manchester United leadership prioritized financial accounting regulations over team retention, treating the sale of homegrown talent as pure profit to comply with Financial Fair Play rules. This strategic choice ultimately strained the relationship between the manager and the club board.
Scott McTominay recorded 12 goals and 4 assists during his debut Serie A campaign with Napoli. Following the transfer, Manchester United struggled to 14th place in the league table after a defeat to West Ham.
The players
Scott McTominay
He is a professional footballer who developed through the Manchester United academy before transferring to the Italian club Napoli.
Erik ten Hag
He served as the manager of Manchester United during the 2024 transfer window and held leadership responsibilities at the club.
Manchester United
This is a professional football club based at Old Trafford that competes in the English Premier League.
Napoli
This is a prominent Italian football club that won the Serie A title during Scott McTominay's debut campaign.
The details
Manchester United leadership sold homegrown players to satisfy strict financial regulations, viewing academy talent as an asset for profit. Erik ten Hag reportedly expressed his frustration with this management strategy before his eventual dismissal.
Timeline
2002: Scott McTominay joined the Manchester United academy.
2024: Manchester United sold Scott McTominay to Napoli.
October 2026: Erik ten Hag discusses the 2024 transfer publicly.
Season Trajectory
The forced sale of academy talent to meet financial thresholds highlights the tension between fiscal compliance and on-pitch performance. This strategy significantly impacted the club's competitive balance as they struggled to maintain their standing in the league table.
The departure of a consistent contributor like McTominay directly impacted the team's depth and production during a difficult season. Fans and analysts continue to track how these financial accounting decisions translate into poor domestic league performance.
The takeaway
Clubs often navigate a difficult trade-off between long-term squad stability and immediate financial regulatory requirements. Fans should monitor how academy systems are valued as accounting tools in the current professional landscape.
Further reading
For more background on major player moves, visit our Soccer section.
Live Poll
Should sports clubs prioritize financial goals over retaining players who have long histories with the team?
