Juliana Gomez Eliminated by P-Black Card at Asian Games
The fencer was disqualified from the round of 16 after a non-combativity penalty against Singaporean rival Elle Meihui Koh.
Updated on Sept. 22, 2026 in Track & Field
Live Poll
Do you agree with the use of P-black cards to resolve non-combativity in fencing matches?
Juliana Gomez exited the women's individual epee competition at the 2026 Asian Games following a P-black card. She trailed Elle Meihui Koh 3-1 when the match was stopped due to non-combativity at the Aichi Sky Expo Hall F in Japan.
Why it matters
In competitive fencing, a P-black card is issued when a fencer fails to engage, resulting in an automatic loss for the athlete with the lower score. This rule is designed to force action during bouts that have stalled for over one minute without a touch.
Gomez trailed 3-1 at the time of the stoppage, following a successful 15-8 victory over Fawzia Alrefae in the previous round. Her performance in Pool 5 concluded with 21 touches scored against 18 touches conceded.
The players
Juliana Gomez
She is a Filipino fencer who competed in the women's individual epee event at the 2026 Asian Games.
Elle Meihui Koh
She is a Singaporean fencer who advanced to the quarterfinals after her bout against Juliana Gomez.
Fawzia Alrefae
She is a fencer from Kuwait who faced Juliana Gomez in the round preceding the round of 16.
Nathaniel Perez
He is a Filipino fencer who participated in the men's individual foil round of 32.
Zheng Zhaoran
He is a fencer from China who defeated Nathaniel Perez in the round of 32.
The details
The bout ended after officials determined non-combativity, a state reached when one minute passes without a touch being scored. Under standard regulations, a second occurrence of this stagnation triggers the P-black card that eliminated Gomez from the tournament.
Timeline
Sept. 22, 2026: The bout and P-black card took place.
Sept. 22-27, 2026: The Asian Games fencing competition period.
Sept. 23, 2026: Upcoming events for Janna Catantan, Samantha Catantan, Christian Concepcion, and Eunice Villanueva.
The Big Picture
The match result follows the specific enforcement pattern established by the International Fencing Federation non-combativity rule. This regulation prevents stagnant play by imposing severe penalties on fencers who fail to score within a one-minute window.
The result eliminates Gomez from the bracket and sends Elle Meihui Koh to the quarterfinal stage of the tournament. The loss also impacts the overall medal standing for the Philippine fencing team as they shift focus to upcoming individual events.
The takeaway
Fencing matches are strictly regulated to maintain a high tempo, meaning passive strategy can lead to an immediate exit. Athletes must maintain offensive engagement throughout the bout to avoid triggering the automatic disqualification mechanism.
What happens next
Janna Catantan and Samantha Catantan are scheduled to compete in the women's individual foil on Sept. 23, 2026. Christian Concepcion and Eunice Villanueva are set to participate in the men's individual sabre events on the same day.
Further reading
For more updates on the tournament, visit the Track & Field section.
Live Poll
Do you agree with the use of P-black cards to resolve non-combativity in fencing matches?
